Thursday, November 19, 2026

WATCH: Trump meets Putin, Xi in China as world powers clash over Iran, Ukraine, nuclear weapons - Reuters

 

by Reuters

"We are really making history," Trump said. "The three of us have a great deal to discuss. No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement.”

 

   

 US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi JInping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin hold trilateral talks at the APEC Summit on November 19, 2026. 

 

US President Donald Trump and Chinese and Russian counterparts Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin finished an unprecedented three-way meeting on Thursday, where they said they would discuss the war in Ukraine and nuclear arms control.

Earlier, sitting around a big round table in a villa in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen, on the sidelines of an Asia-Pacific summit, the leaders of the world's biggest nuclear powers took turns to give opening remarks.

"We are really making history," Trump said. "The three of us have a great deal to discuss.”

“No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement.”

Putin said the three countries have "numerous shared interests in the settlement of regional conflicts, including obviously the conflict in Ukraine.”

Unlike Trump and Putin, Xi - who Chinese state media said was presiding over the meeting - did not make a reference to Ukraine, but said: "History tells us that when major powers live in harmony, the world is at peace. When major powers clash, the world falls into turmoil."

US President Donald Trump, China's President Xi Jinping and Russia's President Vladimir Putin participate in a trilateral meeting during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Economic Leaders' Meeting in Shenzhen, China, November 19, 2026.
US President Donald Trump, China's President Xi Jinping and Russia's President Vladimir Putin participate in a trilateral meeting during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Economic Leaders' Meeting in Shenzhen, China, November 19, 2026. (credit: REUTERS/CARLOS BARRIA)

Trump has insisted nuclear arms control be a central topic of the summit, despite China's repeated objections to joining talks with Washington and Moscow, which have far larger nuclear arsenals.

“It’s not an easy thing to do - give them up,” Trump told Xi and Putin at the start of their meeting.

The trilateral is unlikely to produce major agreements, analysts say, given big differences over Ukraine, Iran, nuclear weapons and trade. But it has unnerved smaller countries that fear their interests might be disregarded.

Xi welcomes Trump at airport in unprecedented move

Trump hailed the lavish welcome Chinese leader Xi gave him as a "big win" on Thursday, ahead of an unprecedented three-way meeting with Xi and Putin.

Trump met Putin and Xi separately ahead of the trilateral talks, calling the Russian leader a "friend." The Kremlin said they discussed the war in Ukraine and that Putin left the meeting in an "excellent" mood.

At the start of a lunch meeting with Xi, Trump said the two sides found "balance" in what is now a "fair" trade relationship. Both feel strongly about oil having to flow through the Strait of Hormuz, which has been disrupted by the Iran war, Trump said.

Russia, China and the United States can strengthen global stability if they cooperate constructively, Putin told his Chinese and US counterparts at their trilateral summit in Shenzhen on Thursday.

Putin also said he, Chinese President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump should discuss global and regional issues as well as energy security.

Trump, Putin meet, discuss Ukraine war in bilateral talks

Trump and Putin addressed each other on friendly terms at the start of their bilateral talks. 

"We've had a great relationship for many years. We know each other for a long time, and I think a lot of wonderful things can come out of this, or at least start. But I think they'll come out of this," Trump told Putin before the pair held bilateral talks.

Putin and Trump discussed the conflict in Ukraine, bilateral ties and their upcoming joint meeting with Xi, Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov was quoted as saying by the state-owned TASS news agency.

The leaders also discussed bilateral ties and their upcoming joint meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in China's southern city of Shenzhen, Ushakov added.

The bilateral meeting went well, and Putin left the talks 'in an excellent' mood, Ushakov said.

Earlier, Putin told APEC leaders that Russia is an integral part of the Asia-Pacific region.

He urged nations to use Russian logistics infrastructure and said Moscow was contributing to regional food and energy security.

"I would like to emphasize that constructive partnership with APEC economies is Russia's strategic course. We are an integral part of the region and make a significant contribution to its economic prosperity," Putin said.

APEC should set a unifying tone and build a constructive agenda for cooperation, which he said the draft of the group's final communique aims for, adding that Moscow supports the document.

President Donald J. Trump and President of China Xi Jinping during a bilateral meeting in Kylin Villa in Shenzhen, China, on Thursday, November 19, 2026.
President Donald J. Trump and President of China Xi Jinping during a bilateral meeting in Kylin Villa in Shenzhen, China, on Thursday, November 19, 2026. (credit: DOUG MILLS/POOL VIA REUTERS)

Trump meets with Chinese President Xi

Speaking to Fox News earlier on Thursday, Trump highlighted the pomp surrounding his arrival, which contrasted with the more muted greeting of other leaders, including Putin. Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi landed without any welcoming ceremony.

Xi greeted Trump at the airport, the first time he has done so with any visiting leader since ‌becoming president, reciprocating his counterpart's gesture at Joint Base Andrews in September when they last met. The leaders also briefly hugged.

"This is a great president, one of the great presidents of China, and he's never gone to the airport to meet somebody," Trump said, when asked what he wanted to get out of the trilateral.

"And not only that, the fanfare, the beauty, the pageantry, the thousands of people, the young children, the soldiers, the whole thing. It was great respect, and I appreciate that. That's a big win for us. It's a big win for China too."

Trump arrived after Xi and Putin delivered pointed speeches at an Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in China's southern tech hub of Shenzhen, denouncing Western trade "protectionism" and sanctions.

During Thursday's APEC proceedings, Xi reiterated his advocacy for what he called "free and open" trade. Western leaders say China's growth model favoring industrial strength over consumers is unfair and creates destabilizing global trade imbalances.

Trump says Board of Trade has brought 'greater balance' to US-China ties

Trump said that the Board of ​Trade that he and Chinese ⁠President Xi Jinping ​agreed to form ​at their summit in Beijing in May had brought "greater balance to a very lopsided relationship" between the two countries.

Trump made his comments at the start of a meeting with Xi during the APEC summit in China and said the US and China had split their tariffs in a fair way.

"We have split up the tariffs and cut it in a very fair way," Trump said in his comments.

"The original relationship with China was very lopsided," he said, while criticizing past US leaders.

Trump has used tariffs as a key tool in foreign and trade policies despite facing legal and judicial setbacks in the US and in spite of criticism from economists and analysts that such an approach risks raising inflation and causing a wider trade war.

US and Chinese officials held the ‌first official meeting of the Board of ​Trade last Friday.

Trump has insisted nuclear arms control be a central topic of the summit, despite China's repeated objections to joining talks with Washington and Moscow, which have far larger nuclear arsenals.

"They're going hot and heavy on building nuclear weapons. I'd love them not to do it," Trump said of China.

"But when they look at me, and they say, ‘OK, we'll do it, but will you reduce your nuclear weapons by 2,000 weapons?’ It's a hard thing to do for me," he said. "It's probably hard for them to do also.”

Could Trump meet Kim Jong Un?

The president has also expressed interest in meeting North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, but there was no confirmation of an imminent encounter.

Trump's Asia trip has offered a chance to showcase US influence, strengthen ties with regional allies and pursue a high-profile diplomatic opening with Xi and Putin.

But the US president will return home facing political challenges, including the fallout from bruising midterm elections, the Nvidia spy scandal and a spate of tech and air travel outages that have rattled Americans.

The diplomatic gathering of the leaders of the world's largest nuclear powers is unlikely to yield major agreements, however, analysts say, given big differences over Ukraine, Iran, nuclear weapons and trade. 

 

Reuters

Source: https://www.jpost.com/international/article-915395

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Trump weighs renewed Iran strikes as Netanyahu pushes for week-long air campaign - report - Idan Kveller

 

by Idan Kveller

Trump is reportedly weighing major strikes on Iran amid Israeli warnings about its missiles, drones, and chemical and biological weapons programs.

 

As President Donald Trump signals a shift in US support for Israel, the future of the alliance, and its implications for American Jewry faces growing uncertainty.
As President Donald Trump signals a shift in US support for Israel, the future of the alliance, and its implications for American Jewry faces growing uncertainty.
(photo credit: Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

US President Donald Trump is weighing another round of extensive military strikes against Iran as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu pushes Washington to join Israel in a four-to-seven-day air campaign, The New York Times reported Wednesday, citing American and Israeli officials briefed on the discussions.

According to the report, Trump has not yet made a decision but is considering fresh Israeli intelligence warnings that Tehran has made progress in rebuilding its missile and drone arsenals and advancing chemical and biological weapons programs.

The president is also assessing what officials described as a window of opportunity created by the substantial American military firepower currently deployed in the Middle East.

The discussions reportedly intensified last week, when Mossad Director Roman Gofman traveled to Washington for meetings with senior administration officials, including CIA Director John Ratcliffe.

IDF Military Intelligence Directorate chief Maj. Gen. Shlomi Binder has also advocated resuming military operations against Iran in discussions with his American counterparts, according to the NYT.

US President Donald Trump speaks in the James S. Brady Press Briefing Room at the White House in Washington, DC, US, November 9, 2026.
US President Donald Trump speaks in the James S. Brady Press Briefing Room at the White House in Washington, DC, US, November 9, 2026. (credit: REUTERS/AARON SCHWARTZ)

However, a senior Israeli official disputed the characterization that Netanyahu had pressured Trump to act. A spokesman for the prime minister said Netanyahu had always worked to “safeguard the security” of Israel.

Divisions within the Trump administration

The possibility of another major military campaign has exposed significant disagreements within the administration over both the reliability of the intelligence and the wisdom of renewed strikes.

According to the NYT, some officials question whether the emerging threats justify a new offensive, particularly following the Republican Party’s defeat in the midterm elections.

The war, which began nearly eight months ago, has contributed to rising prices and failed to deliver the swift victory Trump initially promised, creating political pressure on the White House.

Trump has repeatedly shifted his position in recent months, at times suggesting that the war was over and at others leaving open the possibility of further attacks to prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons.

The newspaper also reported that Trump recently instructed Vice President JD Vance to abandon efforts to reach a negotiated settlement with Tehran, while increasingly favoring sustained economic pressure intended to force Iran to relinquish its nuclear program.

US President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance look on during a Veterans Day ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery in Arlington, Virginia, US, November 11, 2026.
US President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance look on during a Veterans Day ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery in Arlington, Virginia, US, November 11, 2026. (credit: Kylie Cooper/Reuters)

One US official, however, argued that additional major military operations were unnecessary because the administration’s economic pressure campaign had already severely weakened Iran.

Trump: ‘One way or the other, we’ll finish it off’

The report comes hours after Trump told Fox News that American intelligence had indications Iran was exploring chemical and biological weapons as alternatives to nuclear weapons.

“Well, there is indication that Iran is looking at gases, looking at bio because we’ve shut them out with the nuclear,” Trump told White House correspondent Jacqui Heinrich.

The president also confirmed that contacts with Tehran were continuing.

“They want to make a deal, but I want a deal that can be lasting,” Trump said.

Asked whether he would keep American troops in the region until such an agreement was reached, Trump replied: “Yeah, I’m going to finish it off. Yeah, soon. I mean, one way or the other, we’ll finish it off.”

His remarks left open whether Washington intends to conclude the confrontation through diplomacy or renewed military action.

Trump also rejected the suggestion that Vance had been removed from negotiations because of disagreements over the handling of Iran.

“No, no, he’s doing a very good job,” the president said.

While Trump continues to emphasize his desire for a lasting agreement with Tehran, the NYT report suggests that renewed military action remains under active consideration.

For now, the central question remains whether the president will embrace Israel’s proposal for another concentrated air campaign or continue pursuing an agreement through economic and diplomatic pressure.


Idan Kveller

Source: https://www.jpost.com/international/article-915391

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

European countries push new pro-Palestinian UN resolution with expanded criticism of Israel - Mike Wagenheim

 

by Mike Wagenheim

“Instead of focusing on disarming Hamas and ensuring that the terrorist organization never returns to power in the Gaza Strip, they choose to confront Israel with a series of one-sided demands,” Danny Danon, Israel’s U.N. ambassador, told JNS.

 

The city of Ma’ale Adumim, located four miles from Jerusalem’s municipal boundary. Credit: David Mosberg via Wikimedia Commons.
The city of Ma’ale Adumim, located four miles from Jerusalem’s municipal boundary. Credit: David Mosberg via Wikimedia Commons.

 

A group of European Union member states is seeking to advance a United Nations General Assembly resolution on assistance to the Palestinians that includes new demands on Israel and criticism of its policies.

The draft resolution, viewed by JNS and titled “Assistance to the Palestinian People,” was last introduced in 2024. While the previous version focused primarily on economic assistance to the Palestinians, the new draft includes language addressing Israeli settlement construction, humanitarian aid to Gaza and the activities of international organizations operating in the territory.

“Some European countries are seeking to advance a resolution that was intended to assist the Palestinian population, but are effectively turning it into yet another tool in their diplomatic campaign against Israel,” Danny Danon, Israeli ambassador to the United Nations, told JNS.

The new draft urges Israel to halt “settlement expansion,” specifically calling for the cancellation of construction tenders in the E1 area between Jerusalem and Ma’ale Adumim in Judea and Samaria.

On Tuesday, Israeli Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara ordered a halt to the tender process until a new government is formed. The decision postpones the process but does not cancel the planned construction.

The E1 project is particularly contentious because opponents argue that construction there would disrupt Palestinian territorial contiguity in Judea and Samaria, undermining the possibility of a contiguous Palestinian state. Supporters of the project argue that the area would likely remain under Israeli sovereignty in any future agreement with the Palestinians and is strategically important to Israel’s security.

The issue was also cited by British Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband on Tuesday, when the United Kingdom announced sanctions against eight Israeli construction and property development companies involved in settlement expansion.

“That is why my message on E1 is clear: Do not bid, do not build, and do not profit from the destruction of the two-state solution,” Miliband said.

The U.N. draft also calls on Israel to lift restrictions on the entry of humanitarian aid, fuel and equipment into the Gaza Strip and remove restrictions on the operations of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East and international humanitarian organizations. It further calls for international media and donors to be allowed into Gaza.

Approximately seven of the European Union’s 27 member states have expressed reservations about the draft and submitted proposed amendments, according to information obtained by JNS.

Nevertheless, proponents are determined to move forward with the resolution even if those countries, or additional members, oppose it, JNS has learned. The EU delegation to the United Nations told JNS that it had no comment at this time.

“Instead of focusing on disarming Hamas and ensuring that the terrorist organization never returns to power in the Gaza Strip, they choose to confront Israel with a series of one-sided demands,” Danon told JNS of the bill’s sponsors.

“Let me be clear: Israel will not bow to attempts to exploit U.N. institutions to impose a dangerous agenda on our country,” he added.


Mike Wagenheim is a Washington-based correspondent for JNS, primarily covering the U.S. State Department and Congress. He is the senior U.S. correspondent at the Israel-based i24NEWS TV network.

Source: https://www.jns.org/news/israel-news/european-countries-push-new-pro-palestinian-un-resolution-with-expanded-criticism-of-israel

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Musk's solo industry seat on Air Force One signals Trump's tech reset with China - Amanda Head

 

by Amanda Head

The chips at the center of this fight power the AI behind everyday tools such as search, banking and customer service. So who gets to use them, and on what terms, could shape whether those technologies are built on American terms or Beijing's.

 

When Air Force One touched down Wednesday in Shenzhen, Elon Musk was the only executive aboard. In May, President Trump flew to Beijing with a full boardroom, and the empty seats now show how quickly Washington's chip détente with Beijing has cooled.

"I am frustrated when President Trump made it very clear that China should not receive any Nvidia chips above H100s," Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNBC last week. "And so any leakage is very frustrating."

Bessent then went further. "The real story here should be: Did Nvidia know their client, and was there a robust effort at Nvidia to make sure that there was no leakage," he said in the same interview.

The thinner delegation follows a week of upheaval in the chip world. Former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang flew with Trump on Air Force One to Beijing in May, and his place on this trip was in doubt after he resigned amid news reports of an affair with a woman U.S. intelligence suspects of being a Chinese spy. The company at the center of the case, Singapore-based Megaspeed, is suspected of buying Nvidia chips for Southeast Asian data centers and routing them to China, and it reportedly traded more than $4 billion of them over two years. Megaspeed says it takes its export-control obligations extremely seriously.

The one CEO who did make the trip is no Huang critic. Musk is among more than 175,000 signers of a "Stand With Jensen" petition. Still, his solo seat still marks a shift: U.S. officials say Trump does not plan to raise the alleged spy case at Thursday's meeting with Xi Jinping.

Closing the back door

The administration's sharpest move came the day Trump left for Asia. On Nov. 16, Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security issued an interim final rule aimed at a gap in chip controls: Chinese companies renting U.S.-designed computing power from data centers in third countries instead of importing the chips.

The rule was notably not Commerce's own work. The bureau said it was written by and at the direction of the Treasury Department and the National Security Council. Exporters now need a license to ship advanced chips to Brazil, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand and Singapore, and data centers already serving restricted customers have 90 days to get one.

The rule also has teeth. Commerce says it will watch for countries that tolerate evasion and weigh consequences such as import restrictions and new license requirements. Chinese AI firms were reportedly rushing to lock in overseas Nvidia capacity before it took effect. Beijing condemned the measures as overreach.

Nvidia walks away

Nvidia itself is retreating. On Tuesday, acting CEO Colette Kress said the company will no longer sell its H200 chips in China. The same day, Nvidia announced a board-level committee to oversee national security, export compliance and trade risk.

The financial blow had largely been absorbed already. Nvidia guided to $108 billion in quarterly revenue on a forecast that assumes no data-center revenue from China. That suggests the company had been preparing for this outcome before Huang left.

Trump's two-track approach

The president's own posture is more nuanced than a clean break. He has defended Huang and said he would welcome his return and argued that what Nvidia sold China was older technology.

"Selling the other chips is a good thing, not a bad thing," Trump said Monday.

That defense comes with a firm line on Nvidia's most advanced products. Trump has said the Blackwell chips should be reserved exclusively for American customers. He also told Hugh Hewitt the U.S. would be in "bad shape" if it lost its edge in artificial intelligence. 

The White House is also pursuing a coalition strategy. Nine countries signed a U.S. declaration on safeguarding sensitive technologies days before the meeting with China President Xi Jinping.

Critics argue the reset came late. Democrats are probing Trump's approval of H200 sales to China-linked companies. The New York Times reported that Commerce dropped its inquiry into Megaspeed in 2025 after an Nvidia lawyer contacted its agents. Trump advisers have reportedly discussed a possible ouster of Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick.

Still, the administration's direction going into Thursday is clear: tighter controls, a shorter guest list and a Treasury secretary saying publicly where Trump drew the line. The trilateral with Xi and Russian President Vladimir Putin is set for 2:30 p.m. Thursday local time. Whether chips come up or not, Beijing will notice who isn't in the room.


Amanda Head
is White House Correspondent for Just the News. You can follow her here.

Source: https://justthenews.com/government/white-house/musks-solo-industry-seat-air-force-one-signals-trumps-tech-reset-china

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Left-wing scheme to bypass Electoral College gains steam after blue wave, sets up legal battles - Ben Whedon

 

by Ben Whedon

At present, 18 states and the District of Columbia have passed the national popular vote into law. Constitutional scholars have serious doubts about the outcome of the certain litigation on the horizon. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact would not technically eliminate the Electoral College, but as laid out, would render it a nullity.

 

The November "blue wave" that swept across the nation seems poised to advance a movement to eliminate the power of the Electoral College and radically reshape the way the nation chooses its top executive. 

For years now, Democratic-led states have banded together in the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, in which they commit their electoral vote delegates to the winner of the popular vote in a presidential election. Donald Trump won both the popular vote and the Electoral College in 2024. 

Now that Democratic lawmakers have achieved trifectas in typically Republican states, they are well-positioned to expand the compact to include enough states to represent 270 electoral votes, the bare minimum needed for a candidate to win the presidency. While that approach would not technically abolish the Electoral College, it would in practice flip the presidential contest to a popular vote. But the constitutionality of the practice is very much in doubt and Republicans are sure to fight against such an effort.

“It shouldn’t get past the district court,” Attorney General Todd Blanche said this week on “Life, Liberty, and Levin.” “I am optimistic that the Supreme Court will never even have to deal with this […] we will take it to the Supreme Court if we have to.”

Some pundits, however, appear concerned that Republicans seem unaware of the severity of the issue. Writing for the National Review, Inex Feltscher Stepman, a senior policy and legal analyst for the Independent Women's Forum, opined that "it seems like the right has barely realized the importance of the fight that’s about to begin."

At present, 18 states and the District of Columbia have passed the national popular vote into law.  But the initiative could gain as many as five additional states in the near future, given Democrats won trifectas in Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. Should those states implement the compact, it would reach 270 votes and effectively replace the Electoral College.

Time reported that in order for a state to join the compact, it needs to pass legislation through both chambers of its legislature. The governor then needs to sign the legislation for it to become law—or, if they refuse to do so, the state legislature needs to marshal a supermajority to overturn a gubernatorial veto and enact the measure.

Gov.-elect David Crowley, D-Wis., and Gov. Josh Shapiro, D-Pa., have both expressed interest in reforming the Electoral College or switching to a popular vote system, according to SpotlightPA. But neither have started to move legislatively on the matter as of press time. Gov. Mikie Sherrill, D-N.J., this week endorsed eliminating the Electoral College during an appearance on MSNOW, saying “[o]ur votes in New Jersey are worth about one fifth of what a vote in Wyoming is. That’s not democracy.” Her state has already joined the compact.

At present, the compact is not in effect. It is not set to take effect until enough states join it to represent at least 270 electoral votes.  Accordingly, legal challenges to the effort remain in their nascent stages. Republicans have opined on the potential illegality of the compact, but are unlikely to enter litigation until it takes effect, due to standing and ripeness issues. The primary legal challenge to the compact took place in 2019, in Miller v. Washington, in which a voter sued the state over its adoption of the compact. The court dismissed the case, asserting he lacked standing, thus not addressing the underlying merits of the legal and constitutional questions.

Compact would not have prevented Trump's second term

Switching to the popular vote system may not necessarily benefit Democrats. The compact does not take effect until it includes enough states to reach 270 votes, but had it been in place in 2024, for example, heavily Democratic states like California would have been forced to cast their electoral votes for President Donald Trump. But Democrats have their eyes on history, which has seen the Electoral College system almost exclusively work against them in contested races.

The loser of the popular vote has managed to win the presidency twice in recent decades. President George W. Bush pulled off the feat in 2000, while President Donald Trump repeated it in 2016. Both times, the system benefited the Republican candidate. Prior to the 21st Century, that development occurred only three times, in 1824, 1876, and 1888. The 1876 and 1888 elections both saw Republicans claim the presidency, despite a Democrat winning the popular vote. In 1824, John Quincy Adams became president after a deal with Henry Clay to keep out Andrew Jackson, the man who later became the Democratic Party’s first president.

Strictly speaking, members of the Electoral College may cast their vote as they see fit and so-called “faithless electors” sometimes buck the decision of the state they represent. Some states, however, force the electors to vote with their state’s electorate. That matter went to the Supreme Court over the 2016 election, after which some supporters of former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton urged members of the Electoral College to keep President Donald Trump out of the White House. The Supreme Court, in Chiafolo v. Washington, upheld state laws telling their electors how to vote. But while states can generally do what they want with their electors, it remains less clear that they can coordinate with other states on the matter.

States may decide who is a member of the College, but interstate compacts require an act of Congress

Article II, Section 1, Clause 2, gives the states clear authority over the manner in which they select their members of the Electoral College.

Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress: but no Senator or Representative, or Person holding an Office of Trust or Profit under the United States, shall be appointed an Elector.

Article I, Section 10, Clause 3 of the Constitution bars the creation of interstate compacts without the consent of Congress.

No State shall, without the Consent of Congress, lay any Duty of Tonnage, keep Troops, or Ships of War in time of Peace, enter into any Agreement or Compact with another State, or with a foreign Power, or engage in War, unless actually invaded, or in such imminent Danger as will not admit of delay.

The Electoral College is not without benefits, some scholars say

The Supreme Court has previously interpreted this provision in a less absolute manner, finding that congressional consent is only necessary when such a compact would increase the power of the states at the expense of the federal government or other states.

Analysts at the Heritage Foundation have reported that the framers of the Constitution saw several benefits to the Electoral College system. Namely, they argue that:

  • The current system respects regional and cultural differences while uniting the 50 states under one federal government; 

  • Candidates are forced to appeal to a broader cross-section of voters, preventing a "tyranny of the majority" over rural states and encouraging more moderate candidates over radical ones; and 

  • Discourages voter fraud, because the impact of voter fraud is isolated to the specific state where it occurs because winning a state awards the exact same number of electoral votes regardless of whether the margin is 100 votes or 100,000. Thus, fraudulent votes do not carry over to influence the national tally.

The near-certain litigation over the popular vote compact will likely see battle lines drawn between two different visions of the future of America's presidential voting. 


Ben Whedon
is the Chief Political Correspondent at Just the News. Follow him on X.

Source: https://justthenews.com/government/congress/thublue-wave-puts-electoral-college-crosshairs-compact-nears-270-votes

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

The Case for Rebuilding the U.S. Navy - James E. Fanell

 

by James E. Fanell

If there ever was a bipartisan issue to protect America, it must be to restore American maritime power.

 

Three news events occurred in the past month that should remind Americans of the importance of sea power for America’s national security. The first item was the report at the end of September that “Middle East crude oil exports are back at prewar levels.” The second event occurred on October 26, 2026, the 20th anniversary of a Chinese Navy Song-class submarine (SS-321) surfacing within five nautical miles of the Vital Area (VA) of the USS Kitty Hawk (CV-63) while the carrier was conducting flight operations east of Okinawa. The third news event was the November 3 revelation by the Taiwan National Security Council that over 100 PLA Navy warships, including two of three aircraft carriers, were at sea throughout the First and Second Island Chains in October and November.

These reports highlighted the President’s call to rebuild the U.S. Navy via the proposed Golden Fleet, which includes Trump-class battleships. This call to restore American naval power should be front and center for the new Congress. These three events should be a reminder that regardless of political party, rebuilding American sea power requires bipartisan support.

First, the pre-midterm news that the flow of oil out of the Persian Gulf is at or above pre-war levels should have garnered a lot more attention than it received, especially as gas prices are dropping dramatically just two weeks after the midterms, as President Trump had predicted. All of this good news would not have been made possible except for the U.S. Navy’s blockade against Iran. Yes, the joint force helped destroy Iran’s nuclear and conventional forces, but the U.S. Navy made the blockade a reality. It has been the U.S. Navy, not boots on the ground, that has isolated the Iranian regime from sustaining its economy via maritime exports and imports.

But the blockade has come with a heavy price. As Chief of Naval Operations Admiral Daryl Caudle indicated, the Navy will need years for the U.S. Fleet to recover from these unusually long 300-day deployments to the Gulf. As one fellow officer with 40 years of experience told me, “The fleet, especially our carrier strike groups, has been ridden hard and put away wet.” As such, Caudle and other Navy leaders are now planning for a surge in maintenance work that will place even greater pressure on shipyards that are already at overcapacity and overworked.

This reality leads to tough decisions between conducting maintenance and repairs for the existing fleet versus building the Golden Fleet with new warships and submarines. This dichotomy has plagued the Navy and has gradually seen the fleet dwindle in overall size over the past 40 years. For instance, when I was commissioned in 1986, the U.S. Navy had nearly 600 warships and submarines; today that number is under 300.

Second, the twentieth anniversary of the Song-Kitty Hawk Incident marked the beginning of a shift in the naval balance of power in the Western Pacific. While the event received the requisite level of attention at the time, looking back on this event, 20 years later, it seems clear the People’s Republic of China (PRC) used this event as a launching point for the transformation of the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) Navy into the largest, if not the most dominant, maritime power in the Western Pacific.

The Song-Kitty Hawk Incident was a watershed event for the PLA Navy in two ways. First, it legitimized the PRC’s naval modernization program, the largest by any nation since WWII. Second, the incident saw the PLA Navy “break out” beyond the First Island Chain, as Beijing expanded its reach around the world.

This incident was an important inflection point in history, the results of which the U.S. Pacific Command and Fleet are now dealing with as the PRC and PLA Navy daily threaten the existing regional peace and security the Western Pacific has enjoyed since the end of WWII.

As it relates to size, in 2006, according to the Congressional Research Service, the PLA Navy consisted of 222 combatant warships (excluding auxiliary and support ships), while the U.S. Navy consisted of 281 (including auxiliary and support ships, while excluding patrol craft, of which the USN had very few). That gave the U.S. Navy a 59-ship advantage over the PLA Navy. By 2026, the situation had flipped with the PLA Navy having approximately 370 combatants, while the U.S. Navy remained under 300.

Conservatively, that is a 120-ship swing in just 20 years and has placed the PLA Navy as the largest navy on the planet. Principal among that swing has been the building of big-deck warships, aircraft carriers, and amphibious assault ships. Today, the PLA Navy has three aircraft carrier strike groups that were built in just over a decade, with a fourth carrier expected to be launched in 2027.

Likewise, the PLA Navy has built four expeditionary strike groups led by four new amphibious assault carriers, all built in the last decade, demonstrating that the CCP leadership fully intends to deploy the PLA Navy globally, just like the U.S. Navy has been doing since the end of WWII. In addition to the big-deck carriers, the PLA Navy has built hundreds of cruisers, destroyers, frigates, and corvettes—all equipped with long-range ballistic, cruise, or hypersonic anti-ship missile systems that outrange the U.S. Navy.

But nowhere does the impact of the Song-Kitty Hawk Incident become more obvious than in the “far seas” operations of the PLA Navy. While the PLA Navy first sent a training ship, AXT-81 Zheng He, to Hawaii in 1989, the PLA Navy had never deployed more than one or two ships beyond the First Island Chain, and then only on a rare occasion. However, following the Song-Kitty Hawk Incident, the PLA Navy began to “break out” beyond the First Island Chain.

Beginning with the deployment of a five-ship surface action group (SAG) beyond the First Island Chain for the first time in 2007, the PLA Navy expanded its operations into the Philippine Sea between 2007 and 2009, which is now a routine occurrence as PLA Navy warships and submarines operate in these waters nearly daily.

In December 2008, the PLA Navy began its inaugural deployment of its Naval Escort Task Forces (NETF) to the Gulf of Aden. During 18 years of uninterrupted deployments, PLA Navy task force combatants have been sent to a wide variety of ports from Kiel to Cape Town and the west coast of Africa to the east coast of Australia.

During those years, the PRC built a naval base in Djibouti that was opened in 2017, supporting successive task forces through the 49th NETF, which is on station as of this writing. A tremendous level of effort in just 18 years, which originated in the aftermath of the Song-Kitty Hawk Incident.

While there are too many PLA Navy operations beyond the First Island Chain in the past 20 years to chronicle each and every one, a few are worth highlighting.

For instance, in February 2020, a South Sea Fleet–based SAG conducted a 41-day, 14,000-nautical-mile “far sea joint training fleet” deployment. This operation had unique significance for two reasons. First, for the first time, a Chinese SAG crossed the International Date Line in a “combat-ready state,” and second, the exercise was conducted closer to Hawaii than to Guam. In August 2021, four PLAN vessels operated within the U.S. Alaska exclusive economic zone (EEZ) despite the PRC routinely condemning U.S. Navy operations in the PRC’s EEZ in the SCS.

The PLA Navy also expanded its operations alongside allied foreign navies, including those of Russia and Iran, operating in the Mediterranean, off South Africa, in the Gulf of Oman, and in the East China Sea, as well as frequently navigating around Japan. These events are a stark reminder of how the Song-Kitty Hawk Incident of 2006 ushered in an alternative international order that Beijing, Moscow, and Tehran seek to establish and advance.

Beyond these selected examples of PLA Navy SAG operations, PLA Navy carrier operations have also dramatically expanded, especially since 2022. Most notably, by 2025, the PLA Navy’s first two aircraft carriers (Liaoning and Shandong) conducted flight operations in the western Pacific, with the Liaoning operating more than 500 nautical miles east-southeast of Iwo Jima, well outside the second island chain. Again, another result of the 2006 Song-Kitty Hawk Incident.

As it relates to PLA Navy submarine operations, routine “far seas” patrols beyond the First Island Chain became normalized in the decade following the Song-Kitty Hawk Incident. For instance, in 2015, speaking before the House Seapower and Projections Forces subcommittee on the Navy budget, Vice Admiral Joseph Mulloy, deputy chief of naval operations, integration of capabilities and resources, remarked that the PLA Navy submarine force had expanded its missions and patrols. He noted that the PLA Navy submarine force “had three deployments in the Indian Ocean” and that even one Chinese SSBN had conducted a 95-day patrol, which theoretically could have put it in Hawaiian waters, thus able to reach the continental United States with the 7,200 km-range JL-2 ballistic missile.

Third, the news of the PLA Navy surge of 100+ warships, including two of the three aircraft carriers, across the Western Pacific is an unprecedented show of naval forces by the PRC. For instance, never before has the PLA Navy simultaneously deployed three naval task groups from the Northern, Eastern, and Southern Theater Commands.

When combined with the unprecedented circumnavigation of the Philippines by the PLA Navy’s first aircraft carrier, the Liaoning, as well as having its newest carrier, the Fujian, operating in the South China Sea, it seems clear that the primary military training objective for the PLA Navy is what the Chinese call its “Counter Intervention” strategy or what is called “Anti-Access, Area Denial” (A2/AD) in the West.

The purpose of the counterintervention strategy is to create a “no-go zone” for the U.S. and allied navies and other forces through an offensive force disposition. While the PLA Strategic Rocket Force and PLA Air Force provide fires into this “no-go zone,” the presence of PLA naval forces east of Taiwan provides a continuous extended layer of power projection capabilities eastward across the Philippine Sea.

Specifically, these PLA Navy forces are rehearsing establishing air and sea control throughout the area between the First and Second Island Chains. These training objectives are to find, fix, and attack U.S. submarines, surface ships, and aircraft to allow the PLA to either conduct a blockade of Taiwan or, in the ultimate case, an invasion.

The use of PLA naval forces from different theater commands demonstrates that the PLA is also rehearsing command and control capability across theater commands. This effort is clearly an attempt to mimic the U.S. War Department’s “joint force” concept of operations.

This demonstration of a 100+ PLA Navy warship surge into the Philippine Sea also included a likely Type 094/Jin-class ballistic missile submarine that launched an intercontinental ballistic missile from the Yellow Sea into the Chinese mainland. Conducting a submarine-launched ballistic missile test during this Counter Intervention surge by the PLA Navy is a form of “silent intimidation” designed to prevent the U.S. from even considering coming to Taiwan’s defense.

All of these developments demonstrate a continuity of progress by the PLA towards achieving the orders of Xi Jinping and those of other former leaders to the PLA to have the capability to take Taiwan by military force when called upon.

While there are certainly more PLA Navy out-of-area operations over the past 20 years that could be examined, the fact is that before the 2006 Song-Kitty Hawk Incident, the PLA Navy rarely ventured outside the First Island Chain. In the 20 years since that event, the PLA Navy has undeniably broken out beyond the First and Second Island Chains. It has become the most lethal naval force in the Western Pacific and continues in its quest to become the most dominant naval force in the world.

The U.S. government and the U.S. Navy must learn a lesson from these events: Measuring PLA Navy capabilities with a “snap of the chalk line” has been a disastrous approach. Going forward, we must assess the PRC’s maritime power on a trend line, not a snapshot of one moment in time. If we fail to learn this lesson, we may end up seeing PLA Navy ballistic missile submarines patrolling off our shores, along with Chinese carrier and expeditionary strike groups operating in the Western Hemisphere and dominating America’s national security by the end of the next 20 years.

If the Song-Kitty Hawk Incident is going to teach us anything, it is that the Chinese Communist Party’s strategic goals include making the PLA Navy the world’s most powerful naval force. The past 20 years have shown us this reality; the question is, will we respond and restore America’s Navy size and power in order to maintain the advantage we’ve had in naval power for the past 100 years?

Bottom line: these three events should serve as a reminder to the new Congress that they must fund the rebuilding of our Navy. If there ever was a bipartisan issue to protect America, it must be to restore American maritime power. We have no time to lose. 


James E. Fanell

Source: https://amgreatness.com/2026/11/19/the-case-for-rebuilding-the-u-s-navy/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Texas Lawmaker Demands DHS Investigation into Three Foreign-Born Islamists Leading Massive Building Projects - Debra Heine

 

by Debra Heine

Rep. Keith Self (R-Texas) sent a formal letter to Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin Wednesday morning, alleging that Hamed Ghazali, Main Al Qudah and AbdulRahman Kattab have documented connections to Muslim Brotherhood networks and jihadist organizations.

 

A Texas congressman is sounding alarm bells about three notorious foreign-born Islamists in Texas, demanding that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) immediately investigate their immigration histories, associations, and activities to determine whether deportations are warranted.

Rep. Keith Self (R-Texas) sent a formal letter to Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin Wednesday morning, alleging that Hamed Ghazali, Main Al Qudah and AbdulRahman Kattab have documented connections to Muslim Brotherhood networks and jihadist organizations.

Self states in the letter that Ghazali, the Egyptian-born director of the Houston Quran Academy and chairman of the Muslim American Society’s Council of Islamic Schools,  has “documented connections to the Muslim Brotherhood and other jihadist organizations.”

Al Qudah, according to the letter, “entered the U.S. in 2000 on a temporary religious worker visa and was subsequently placed in removal proceedings.” His request for relief was rejected by the Sixth Circuit in 2013, but he later obtained permanent residence. He and his family allegedly have documented ties to the Jordanian Muslim Brotherhood, which has been designated a terrorist organization by President Trump.

AbdulRahman Kattab is an Egyptian-born Imam and resident scholar at the Northside Islamic Center of San Antonio, and his immigration/citizenship status is unclear, the letter states.  Kattab has allegedly expressed support for the  October 7, 2023, Hamas massacre and the expansion of Sharia.

According to the RAIR Foundation, an investigative news platform that unmasks Islamic supremacists, Ghazali helped build a North American Islamic education network and is now positioned to receive Texas taxpayer funding for his Houston school, Qur’an Academy Spring, through the state’s school choice voucher program.

Ghazali was a prominent Muslim Brotherhood leader in America, explicitly named in the infamous 1991 “Explanatory Memorandum: On the General Strategic Goal for the Group in North America,” which calls for “Civilization Jihad”, to sabotage and dismantle Western civilization. Hamed Ghazali sat on the Muslim Brotherhood “Board of Directors” in 1992 with, among others, Ahmed Elkadi, the General Mas’ul, or national leader, of the U.S. Muslim Brotherhood during the 1980s.

Ghazali ran the largest pre-9/11 jihadi recruiting organization in America, known as “Ghazali Islamic Video” (GIV). It was on GIV that Ghazali interviewed the top aide to Osama bin Laden mentor and co-founder of Al-Qaeda, and solicited support for the “martyrs” in Palestine who are “fighting for [Allah].”

Al Qudah,  according to RAIR, has been building “a $70–80 million, 30-acre fully autonomous Sharia-adherent Islamic enclave” called the Al-Huda Islamic Center in rural Katy, Texas.

RAIR reported back in May that the “sharia city” aims to be “a self-sustaining parallel society featuring a grand mosque, K-12 school, Islamic university, apartments, health clinic, sports fields, and its own strip mall.”

The developers reportedly used Texas school voucher taxpayer dollars to fund the project.

As reported at RAIR,  Al Qudah entered the United States from Jordan in 2000 on a “temporary religious worker” visa to replace the founding imam of the Islamic Society of Arlington in Texas, a mosque under intense pre-9/11 scrutiny for its direct ties to Osama bin Laden’s terror network.

Kattab, according to a RAIR investigation, is leading a multi-million-dollar project that includes the building of “a 33,000-square-foot mosque and community center on 7.25 acres of land” in one of San Antonio’s fastest-growing and most affluent northern suburbs.

Groundbreaking for the Northside Islamic Center of San Antonio (NICSA) took place in April 2024 and construction is ongoing, according to the report.

The Islamic center is located not far from the U.S. military training installation at Camp Bullis, and will accommodate more than 2,000 Muslim adherents.

Kattab has “publicly celebrated the October 7 Hamas attacks as a ‘day of remembrance’ for Muslims, invoked anti-Jewish tropes about wealth and influence, and prayed for Muslim victory over Jerusalem,” RAIR reported.

In his letter, Self stated that the additional information provided in appendices warranted further investigations into Ghazali,  Al Qudah and Kattab.  He requested a written response within 30 days detailing any findings and enforcement actions. 


Debra Heine

Source: https://amgreatness.com/2026/11/18/texas-lawmaker-demands-dhs-investigation-into-three-foreign-born-islamists-leading-massive-building-projects/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Free speech groups gang up on deep-blue states to block AI censorship, government mouthpiece laws - Greg Piper

 

by Greg Piper

Social media trade group sues New York to stop tobacco-style warning labels that users can't click through, similar to Colorado's blocked law. ACLU joins libertarians against Minnesota AI "nudification" law that goes way past nudity.

 

A common campaign theme among victorious Democrats in this month's agenda-setting midterms was stiffer regulation of social media and artificial intelligence, seeking to build on the momentum of Meta's massive settlements with dozens of states and New Mexico separately for data collection and design choices pertaining to children.

But cross-ideological legal challenges to deep-blue states' laws, and their mixed record of defending similar laws in court, cast doubt on how much the victors can deliver without wasting taxpayer dollars on fruitless legal defenses.

Tech industry trade group NetChoice, representing social media companies including Meta and X, sued New York to block its new law that would slap recurring tobacco-style warnings on "addictive" features in Empire State users' feeds with escalating duration and frequency, portraying them as annoying pop-ups as well as unconstitutional compelled speech.

The warnings, which would initially cover a quarter of the page for 10 seconds, then three-quarters and 30 seconds after the first three hours and subsequently every hour, would apply to everyone the platform has not "reasonably determined" is older than 17. 

NetChoice litigation blocked a similar Colorado law this month and targeted California's "censorship labels" last month, deeming them "even more extreme" than Colorado's.

Such warnings resemble the state-prescribed disclaimers that obscure AI-generated political satire and ruin the joke. First Amendment litigation quickly invalidated them in Hawaii and California and is ongoing against a similar New Mexico law.

 


Greg Piper

Source: https://justthenews.com/index%2Ephp/nation/free-speech/free-speech-groups-gang-deep-blue-states-block-ai-censorship-government

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Muslim, Zionist and unapologetic - Shimon Cohen

 

by Shimon Cohen

Muslim Zionist advocate Sara Zoabi criticizes Arab MKs who left the plenum during "Hatikvah". Speaking to Arutz Sheva, she explains why she proudly sings the anthem and reveals the steep personal cost of her views, even among those close to her.

 

Proud of her country. Sara Zoabi
Proud of her country.                                                                             Sara ZoabiCourtesy

 

In an interview with Arutz Sheva, Muslim Zionist advocacy activist Sara Zoabi addressed Arab lawmakers' departure from the Knesset plenum during the singing of the national anthem, and Mansour Abbas's decision to remain in the chamber but not sing.

Zoabi began with a reminder, "Knesset members stand in the plenum and pledge allegiance to the State of Israel, saying: 'I pledge to bear allegiance to the State of Israel and faithfully fulfill my mandate in the Knesset'. I don't understand how they pledge allegiance to the State of Israel, disrespect it and leave the chamber when the anthem begins. This is the very same country to which you pledge allegiance... It doesn't add up".

Addressing the argument, also voiced by Jews, that Muslims cannot be expected to sing the words "a Jewish soul yearns", Zoabi said, "I am indeed a proud Israeli Arab Muslim woman, but I see no contradiction between these things. People ask me how, as an Arab Muslim, I can sing 'a Jewish soul yearns', and I ask: What does that have to do with it? Who said I have to be Jewish to love my country and respect the Jewish people and their history? I know exactly what the anthem says and understand every word of it. It speaks of the Jewish dream of being a free people in their own land. So what? Because I am an Arab Muslim, am I not allowed to be moved by that hope?".

Zoabi said, "I sing 'Hatikvah' not because I am Jewish, but out of solidarity with the Jewish people and love for my country, which has protected me and given me security, freedom, rights and equality. As an Arab woman, I can live here with my identity, my religion and my faith. I can speak freely and stand up for my rights. When I sing 'Hatikvah', I am not only honoring the history of the Jewish people, but expressing solidarity with and gratitude to my country, which is my home".

She also said she sees no need to change even a single word or comma in the anthem, "This is Israel's anthem, and I am proud to sing it exactly as it is. I am not asking the Jewish people to change their history and their anthem to fit my identity".

Zoabi said, "I am an Arab and a Muslim, and I respect the fact that this is the nation-state of the Jewish people, who have suffered throughout history". She added, "I have been fortunate to live here in Israel alongside the Jewish people, and I do not take that for granted".

However, Zoabi made clear that she does not demand that anyone be forced to sing the anthem. She understands Arab citizens who feel its words do not represent them, but believes they, too, should respect the state's symbols, particularly Knesset members, who represent the state by virtue of their membership in the Knesset.

She said, "Love of one's country and respect for its symbols should not depend on any other consideration. As an Arab, I am not giving up my language, identity or religion, but I am also unwilling to give up my love for my country and the Jewish people. Some people think that because of my love for Israel and the Jewish people, I am less Arab and less Muslim, and that I am an infidel. Who gave them the right to decide who I am? I do not have to choose between my identity and my love for my country and the Jewish people and my belief in their rights. When I sing 'Hatikvah', I feel pride, belonging and emotion. I do not have to be Jewish to love the Jewish people, and I do not have to change the anthem to feel that I belong to this country. I do not have to apologize for my love for the Jewish people. I sing 'Hatikvah' proudly, with my head held high".

Asked about the consequences of her views, Zoabi said she has paid, and continues to pay, a heavy price in her personal life as well, but preferred not to elaborate.

She said, "I have paid and am still paying a heavy price, including at the hands of those closest to me, but I will not give up on my truth".


Shimon Cohen

Source: https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/436629

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

AI Doomers Agree on One Thing: Someone Else Should Control Your Future - Jordan Schachtel

 

by Jordan Schachtel

Anthropic’s critics are right to question its power grab, yet they are considerably less interested in examining their own.

 

Today marks Anthropic’s much-hyped stock market debut. As its founding team reaches billionaire status in the coming days, we are left with some questions before the public: who gets to control AI, and how much power should they be allowed to wield?

AI doomers have split into two distinct factions: those who believe that Anthropic should control AI and those who believe that American innovation must grind to a halt under a forcibly installed European-style regulatory regime.

On Wednesday, a group of prominent AI doomers put together a “MisAnthropic Statement” targeting Anthropic. But Anthropic is the most doomery company in the industry, so what gives?

Released Wednesday, the statement accuses Anthropic of exploiting its safety reputation to advance its commercial and political ambitions. Signatories include the likes of Future of Life’s Max Tegmark, Dan Hendrycks of the Center for AI Safety (CAIS), MIRI president Nate Soares, and ControlAI’s leadership.

Within the doomer universe, there are two broad camps. The Anthropic loyalists believe the right people (think: ideologically aligned) must win the race because everyone else is too reckless to be trusted. The shutdown faction behind the “MisAnthropic” memo thinks the race itself must be stopped altogether, resulting in the future being ceded to China.

We have monopolistic doomers on one side of the fence and the perma-moratorium doomers on the other.

They disagree about whether Anthropic should keep building, but they share a deeper conviction that unites the two sides. Both have made it clear that they believe that ordinary people cannot be trusted with their personal sovereignty. And therefore, an “enlightened” group of Bay Area minds must take charge for them.

The MisAnthropic Statement is unintentionally revealing. Its signatories condemn Anthropic’s “reckless attempt to amass power in the name of the greater good.” Yet organizations across this ecosystem, like CAIS, the Future of Life Institute, MIRI, and ControlAI, are themselves seeking to impose their will upon the AI ecosystem by attempting their own power grab.

Anthropic and the “purist” doomers differ on the end game, but both sides want to take power from the individual and grant it to a centralized authority that will determine the future.

Nirit Weiss-Blatt has contributed valuable work documenting the authoritarian implications of AI doomerism. She’s tracked how the doomers have inundated the field with proposals for monitoring researchers, restricting computing, and expanding government enforcement over people who just want the right to compute lawfully and freely.

Doomers frequently advance nonsensical hypotheticals about sentient machine power, but their solutions always involve demanding very real human power to prevent human flourishing.

Consider MIRI’s proposed international agreement, which calls on the U.S. to partner with China to maintain a complete tyranny over the AI ecosystem. They want to use the power of government to put a permanent lid on AI innovation. On top of that, their framework seeks to consolidate all AI chips into declared facilities, monitor their use, and restrict certain research, presumably on ideological grounds.

The anti-Anthropic doomers are out in the open, proposing tyrannical enforcement mechanisms governing hardware, scientific work, and access to advanced computing.

Take a look at ControlAI’s proposals for UK legislation prohibiting superintelligent AI and a “kill-switch” amendment. Its founder, Andrea Miotti, has proposed an international consortium with an exclusive mandate over critical frontier research—“the world’s only artificial general intelligence project”—alongside compute limits and emergency shutdown infrastructure.

The Future of Life Institute’s infamous 2023 AI pause letter, written in haste when AI systems were incredibly rudimentary, called for the American government to impose a sweeping, unconstitutional moratorium on AI companies that would not suspend innovation indefinitely.

“AI Safety” is an Orwellian term. It really means “AI Control.” These organizations describe their preferred policies as safeguards. Yet both Anthropic and its Stop AI rivals ask us to accept the total concentration of power, all rolled up into singular entities.

Anthropic has already done this with its corporate structure. According to reports, its founders have retained a permanent 50.1 percent of voting power through a special corporate vehicle that is not accessible to investors.

Sure, attempting to wrest founder control is common in technology companies that go public. But their claim that they deserve complete and total trust over humanity’s future is another matter.

Anthropic has branded itself as the one and only AI company trusted to build the most powerful frontier technologies. The perma-moratorium faction objects to that notion while advancing its own systems of centralized control.

That is why open-source technologies, which both control factions fiercely oppose, are so critical to our future. Open-source and open-weight models distribute capabilities more widely and in permissionless fashion, and they create a natural check on the centralization of power.

Decentralization is not a one-shot magical solution, but it serves as the antidote to the idea that one company, one regulator, or one international committee of “experts” can become the permanent enforcer of what everyone else must do.

Both Anthropic and the maximalist doomers have ideas that will harm competition, and if they get their way, America will effectively surrender the AI race to China.

We don’t have to make the choice between Anthropic’s monopolistic pursuits and the shutdown lobby’s authoritarian permission regime. There is another option for the American people.

Americans must be allowed to lawfully build and compete on a free and fair playing field, and we should wholly reject the idea that it would be for the best to give up control over the future “for the greater good” to a faction of AI doomers. 


Jordan Schachtel

Source: https://amgreatness.com/2026/11/19/ai-doomers-agree-on-one-thing-someone-else-should-control-your-future/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter