by Benjamin Baird
Hat tip: Dr. Charles Bensoussan
By assigning texts by Islamist sympathizers who in some cases have embedded with their subjects, Menoret portrays these radicals as harmless souls seeking escape from imperialist oppression through spiritual rebellion.
[NER title is "Brandeis Professor Advises Hanging Out with Terrorists."]
The Renée and Lester Crown Professor of Modern Middle East Studies, Menoret specializes in the people and culture of Saudi Arabia, the epicenter of Wahhabi Islam. Despite the strict and brutal application of Shariah law in the Arabian peninsula, his scholarship overwhelmingly frames Islamists as the marginalized victims of state oppression.
Menoret teaches five anthropology courses, two of which are examined below. The syllabi for "Islamism" (Anthropology 141a) and "Culture and Power in the Middle East (CPME)" (Anthropology 118b) exemplify his soft approach to Islamism. By assigning texts by Islamist sympathizers who in some cases have embedded with their subjects, Menoret portrays these radicals as harmless souls seeking escape from imperialist oppression through spiritual rebellion.
The readings for "Islamism" include Francois Burgat's Face to Face with Political Islam, which attacks the West's "collective ignorance" of Islam and attempts to hide its religious foundation by cloaking it in Arab nationalism: "Much more than a hypothetical 'resurgence of the religious,' it should be reiterated that Islamism is effectively the reincarnation of an older Arab nationalism, clothed in imagery considered more indigenous." Throughout the work, Burgat sympathizes with Islamism, which he prefers to call "political Islam," to imply a nonexistent moderation derived from adopting Western political ideas.
Also assigned is Charles Hirschkind's article "The Ethics of Listening: Cassette-Sermon Audition in Contemporary Egypt," which recounts the author's acculturation through participation in a series of sessions with Egyptian Islamists as they listen to recorded copies of radical sermons. The reader almost forgets that Hirschkind is in the company of violent extremists, as they smoke cigarettes, drink tea, and tell jokes, all the while listening to impassioned exhortations from Islamist tapes banned in many Muslim countries.
Naturally, Menoret assigns CPME his own 2014 book Joyriding in Riyadh: Oil, Urbanism, and Road Revolt. The culmination of years of study in Saudi Arabia, Menoret admits he intended the book to "critique widespread stereotypes on Arab youth and to show that Islamic groups were not the hotbeds of religious radicalization." By accompanying young Islamist men as they participate in exhilarating street races, Menoret echoes the theme so common in his classroom: Islamists are nothing more than harmless, innocent reflections of rebellious American youth—a Muslim version of Fast and Furious.
But Menoret's thesis collapses when, after spending time in a rural Saudi village, he is threatened with conversion and later forcibly expelled by conservative tribesmen grown weary of his presence. As a Western tourist, he is warned that his host's relatives "have weapons, and they have been on the lookout since this afternoon." Apparently, these harmless Islamists were not as enamored with his cultural exoticism—a fitting example of the dangers of jihad tourism.
CPME's readers of Paul Rabinow's book Reflections of Fieldwork in Morocco are instructed—as noted in a review that quotes the book—to "completely subordinate one's own code of ethics, conduct, and world view, to 'suspend belief.'" Jettisoning one's critical faculties is a prescription for being propagandized, a perversion of higher education. Since Islamist ideals are so radically incompatible with universally acknowledged standards of human decency, most students can accept them only by suppressing their reason and morals.
By assigning one of the most politically divisive apologias for Islamism, Faisal Devji's essay "The Terrorist as Humanitarian," Menoret teaches students in CPME that Islamists are simply humanitarians and philanthropists. Devji quotes approvingly Osama bin Laden and Ayman al-Zawahiri and praises their alleged underlying messages of victimhood and charity in the name of Islam. He even contends that humanity "lies at the heart of militant action"—an indefensible claim that whitewashes cold-blooded murder.
Yet students enrolled in "Islamism" are taught that their preconceived notions of Islam and Muslim culture are necessarily bigoted. Key among its assignments is the late Edward Said's Orientalism, the fatally flawed and regrettably influential work that proclaims a "subtle and persistent Eurocentric prejudice against Arabo-Islamic peoples and their culture." (In fairness, Menoret assigns Bernard Lewis's comprehensive critique of Orientalism in CPME, but in this course, Said stands alone.)
Menoret shares Said's antipathy for Israel, having supported the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement as a professor at New York University's Abu Dhabi campus by signing a petition aimed at convincing the University to sever Israeli academic and business relationships. More broadly, his syllabi indicate his predisposition for Said's unfounded condemnation of Western scholarship on the region.
Accordingly, Menoret frames ethical questions in the language of postcolonialism. In the CPME-assigned Anthropology and the Colonial Encounter, author Tal Asad describes post-WWII anthropologists as "Europeanized elites" studying the "'traditional' masses in the Third World" as part of their "bourgeois disciplines."
For Asad, Western research on the Middle East can only occur within a dynamic of "power relationships" between the "dominating" Europeans and the "dominated" non-Europeans. Consequently, he argues that most traditional scholarship on the region has been conducted "toward maintaining the structure of power represented by the colonial system."
Menoret's reliance on postcolonial theory reflects its disproportionate influence on the field of Middle East studies. Furthermore, he is part of a much larger coterie of scholars who whitewash Islamism to portray it as harmless despite all the chaos and violence it has spawned across the Middle East and in the West. This approach is disarming the West by blinding it to the enemies of liberal, pluralistic Western culture—a deadly error we cannot afford to commit.
The Crown Center for Middle East Studies at Brandeis claims to be "committed to a balanced and dispassionate approach to the Middle East." Yet, by "hanging out with Islamists" and demanding his students do the same, Menoret reveals the cynicism and hollowness at the Crown Center's core.
Benjamin Baird is a graduate of Middle Eastern studies from the American Military University, an Army veteran of Iraq and Afghanistan, and a staff writer for the Conservative Institute. This article was sponsored by Campus Watch, a project of the Middle East Forum.
Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter
Copyright - Original materials copyright (c) by the authors.