Egypt Renews Nuclear Program

by MEMRI

Egypt recently announced the renewal of its plan to establish a nuclear power plant. This intention was expressed in statements made by the Egyptian minister of electricity and energy in mid-September 2013 during meetings he held with International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) officials, and in a speech given by Egyptian President 'Adly Mansour on the 40th anniversary of the 1973 war last week.
The Egyptian nuclear program began in the 1950s with the intent to establish a nuclear power plant in a dedicated site in the city of Al-Dab'a in the Matrouh governorate in Northwest Egypt, on the shore of the Mediterranean. This plan was suspended in 1986 following the Chernobyl disaster, but was revived in the early 21st century under President Hosni Mubarak, possibly due to the leniency of the U.S. and the West towards the nuclear programs of India, Pakistan, and North Korea, as well as the perception that a nuclear program would help strengthen Egypt's position as a regional power.[1] Under Mubarak, the project ran into difficulties, and after his regime was ousted in February 2011 it was halted completely. After the anti-Mubarak revolution, the residents of Al-Dab'a, who had objected for years to the establishment of a nuclear site in the city - citing health and safety concerns, and claiming that they had rights to the land - invaded the site and wreaked havoc there.[2]
During his brief term in office, ousted president Muhammad Mursi also considered the possibility of renewing the nuclear project. While on a visit Russia in April 2013, Mursi called on Russia to develop Egypt's peaceful nuclear program and to construct nuclear power plants in the country.[3] However, no significant developments occurred during Mursi's term, and the residents of Al-Dab'a continued to object to the project.
According to reports in the last two weeks, the Egyptian army has reached an understanding with the Al-Dab'a residents on restoring its control over the site, which enables the project to move forward. It seems that the renewal of the nuclear project is motivated by the current regime's desire to win internal legitimacy and portray itself as being able to restore Egypt's status as a regional power.
It should be mentioned that Egypt is a signatory to the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty (NPT) since 1981 and has made efforts in international circles to disarm the Middle East, and especially Israel, of weapons of mass destruction. Egypt repeatedly stresses that its nuclear program is for civilian purposes and is meant to meet its energy needs, and that it would operate in full coordination with the IAEA. However, Egypt's decision to renew its nuclear program may also be a signal from it and its gulf allies to the U.S., in light of the recent signs of an Iran-U.S. rapprochement and the possibility that the U.S will recognize a nuclear Iran.[4] Accordingly, there have been increased fears of a possible nuclear arms race in the Middle East.
It should also be mentioned that, alongside Egypt's declaration of the renewal of its nuclear program, and, on the other hand, the beginning of the disarmament of Syria's nuclear weapons arsenal, official Egyptian media published several articles calling on Arab countries to preserve their weapons of mass destruction as a deterrent.[5]
This report will review the recent developments in the Egyptian nuclear program.

President Mansour In Speech Commemorating October 6 Victory: We Will Renew Al-Dab'a Nuclear Project

As stated, the issue of renewing the Egyptian nuclear program was raised in mid-September 2013. Egyptian Electricity and Energy Minister Ahmad Imam discuss the Egyptian nuclear program with IAEA officials on the margins of the IAEA conference in Vienna, adding that its execution depends on the approval of the Egyptian parliament, which is to be elected in a few months' time after a new constitution is approved. Imam stressed that the program would be conducted in full coordination with the IAEA.[6]

Some three weeks later, in a speech commemorating the 40th anniversary of the 1973 war, Egyptian President 'Adly Mansour officially announced the renewal of the nuclear project in Al-Dab'a and the commencement of the first steps towards establishing peaceful nuclear power plants. He said: "In light of the challenges we face in the field of energy, I declare the start of a project to establish peaceful nuclear power plants. Al-Dab'a will be the first site to be examined. This is a national project that, over the coming decades, will help meet one of the most important development demands for the next generations – a demand [whose fulfillment] Egypt yearns for and deserves. In this context, let me praise the patriotic [commitment] of the Egyptian [citizens] in Al-Dab'a towards realizing this promising project."[7]

President Mansour's science advisor, 'Essam Heggy, also stressed the importance of renewing the Egyptian nuclear program. In an interview with the daily Al-Masri Al-Yawm, which was published the day after Mansour's speech, he said: "Being that 90% of Egyptian energy relies on fossil fuels, there is no alternative but to renew the Egyptian nuclear energy program so that nuclear energy will become the primary source of energy and electricity[-production] in Egypt."[8]

After President Mansour's declaration of the re-launching of the nuclear program, reports indicated that a series of meetings had been held at the ministry of electricity and energy, attended by the heads of Egypt's three bodies in charge of nuclear energy – The Nuclear Power Plant Authority (NPPA), the Nuclear Materials Authority and the Atomc Energy Authority – in order to jump-start the program and lay down the necessary infrastructure for it. Among other things, they discussed the transfer of the Al-Dab'a site to the responsibility of the NPPA, and the question of whether to accept public bids for the project from around the world or assign it in advance to a specific company.[9]

Breakthrough After Years Of Stagnation: Al-Dab'a Residents Withdraw Objection 

To Establishing Nuclear Power Plant

Throughout the years, the residents of Al-Dab'a have been objecting to the establishment of a nuclear power plant in their city. The residents' protest against the nuclear program was also expressed on social media, and in 2009, a Facebook campaign was launched against the nuclear project due to the many dangers it entails. 

Facebook.com/dabaafree2012, October 8, 2013

After the January 25, 2011 revolution, the residents of Al-Dab'a took over the site intended for the nuclear power plant and damaged it, while demanding compensation for damages they claim to have suffered as a result of the project and presenting this as a condition for handing the site over to authorities.

Al-Dab'a residents protest in January 2013: "No to nuclear power"[10]

However, September 2013 saw a significant development: after two weeks of negotiations the residents of Al-Dab'a reached an agreement with the army and handed over control of the site. The sides agreed that, upon the approval of the nuclear program by the future parliament, which is to be elected in a few months after the approval of a new constitution, the residents harmed by the project would be compensated, and all lawsuits and legal proceedings against residents who invaded the site would be dropped.[11] This development was presumably one of the factors that enabled the declaration of the renewal of the nuclear program.

Celebrating the transfer of the Al-Dab'a site to the army in late September 2013[12]

Electricity And Energy Minister: "The Nuclear Dream Will Finally Be Realized"

On October 8, 2013, two days after President Mansour announced the renewal of the nuclear program, the Egyptian daily Al-Ahram reported on a conference it had sponsored on the topic of the electricity crisis in Egypt, which was attended by officials of the electricity and energy ministry and of bodies in charge of the nuclear energy domain. At the conference, Electricity and Energy Minister Ahmad Imam reviewed the reasons for the crisis and indicated a gap between Egypt's electricity production capabilities and growing consumption rate. According to him, Egypt's electricity production was harmed by improper maintenance of power plants and the electrical grid, a lack of fuels, climate change and the security situation.

Imam promised that the nuclear program would substantially improve electricity production in Egypt, and said: "The nuclear dream will finally be realized now that Egyptian President 'Adly Mansour has announced the start of a project to build a nuclear power plant for civilian use and defined it as a national project that will meet one of the main development demands of the coming decades. The possibility of implementing the nuclear project is within reach, now that the army has received the land [intended] for the project in Al-Dab'a at a ceremony witnessed by the entire world. [This,] alongside furious efforts to prepare the site, ahead of accepting international bids to establish a nuclear power plant soon. [This plant] will save Egypt from the dark crisis, increase its [energy] production capabilities... end the [long] period of a gap between production and consumption, provide electricity for all residents, achieve various development goals, and prevent blackouts..."[13]

NPPA Chairman: The Project Will Commence In 18 Months At Most

At the same conference, Dr. Khalil Yasso, chairman of Egypt's Nuclear Power Plant Authority, said: "Egypt desperately needs nuclear power plants, especially in light of the limited [sources of] conventional energy. As for the Al-Dab'a site – we are now coordinating the transfer of this site with the army, and have formulated a swift plan to establish residential and administrative quarters for workers on the project in order to prepare the site. In addition, we are now examining the establishment of an entire complex for the Al-Dab'a residents, in order to build mutual trust with them and alleviate their fears and misconceptions about the project. [We also intend to] inform them about all the international research conducted in Al-Dab'a, which proved that it is appropriate for the project and contains all the [necessary] safety measures..."

Yasso added: "The project will commence in one year to 18 months at most. In the first phase, two units will be established, each producing 900-1,950 megawatts. The completed project will produce 8,000 megawatts. The cost is $5 billion per unit... We cannot start the project without the broad consent of society, [including] parties, NGOs, and first and foremost the residents of Al-Dab'a, after we satisfy them and assure them that this project is for Egypt's future.

"The matter of nuclear safety was a top priority of research conducted for the power plant. We have adopted the highest security standards accepted in the world, and we [will not] take a single step in the nuclear project if it harms the residents. We have delayed entering into this field for a long time, while a country like China constructed 28 nuclear power plants during the same time, Russia constructed 10 plants, and the UAE is constructing two."[14]

Endnotes:

[1] See MEMRI Inquiry & Analysis Series Report No. 118, Egypt Rethinks Its Nuclear Program Part I: Scientific and Technological Capability Vs. International Commitments, January 14, 2003.

[2] Al-Shurouq (Egypt), January 16, 2012.

[3] Alarabiya.net, April 20, 2013.

[4] See MEMRI Special Dispatch No. 5462, Editorials In Gulf Press Criticize American-Russian Deal, U.N. Resolution On Syria's Chemical Weapons: A Fefeat For U.S.; Assad Can Continue Slaughtering Syrians Using Conventional Weapons, October 1, 2013; and MEMRI Inquiry & Analysis Series Report No. 888, Iran Becomes A Nuclear Threshold State, October 5, 2012.

[5] Al-Ahram (Egypt), October 2, 9, 2013.

[6] Moheet.com, September 18, 2013.

[7] Al-Ahram (Egypt), October 5, 2013.

[8] Al-Yawm Al-Sabi' (Egypt), October 7, 2013.

[9] Al-Ahram (Egypt), October 7, 2013.

[10] Al-Yawm Al-Sabi' (Egypt), January 13, 2013.

[11] Al-Dustour Al-Asli (Egypt), September 30, 2013.

[12] Al-Dustour Al-Asli (Egypt), September 30, 2013.

[13] Al-Ahram (Egypt), October 8, 2013.

[14] Al-Ahram (Egypt), October 8, 2013. Dr. Ibrahim Al-'Asiri, an advisor to the NPPA, told the Egyptian daily Al-Tahrir that the project includes 8 plants, and that each plant will take some 4 years to construct. Another advisor on the Egyptian nuclear program, Dr. Yusri Ibrahim, explained that, once a plant is built, it takes another year until it becomes operational.  Al-Tahrir (Egypt), October 8, 2013.

MEMRI

Source: http://www.memri.org/report/en/0/0/0/0/0/0/7458.htm

Copyright - Original materials copyright (c) by the authors.