Monday, June 6, 2022

From Washington to Jerusalem the Conspiracies are Unravelling - Caroline Glick

 

by Caroline Glick

Over the past generation, leftist ideologues seized control over our state prosecution and law enforcement agencies and transformed our institutions of law into arms of the political left.

 


In the U.S. as in Israel, the polarization between left and right grows from day to day. Our societies have never been more divided. A chief source of the social and ideological divide is the politicization of our countries’ legal systems. Over the past generation, leftist ideologues seized control over our state prosecution and law enforcement agencies and transformed our institutions of law into arms of the political left.

In recent weeks we have witnessed the consequences of this takeover in courtrooms in Washington and Jerusalem.

Tuesday Attorney Michael Sussmann, a former partner at the Washington law firm Perkins Coie, which represents the Democrat Party and represented Hillary Clinton’s 2016 presidential campaign was acquitted in Washington, DC’s Federal District Court of the charge of lying to the FBI. A few months before the 2016 elections, Sussmann initiated a meeting with his friend James Baker who at the time served as the FBI’s General Counsel. In that meeting, Sussmann shared allegations that Donald Trump had untoward relations with the Kremlin. Sussmann alleged that the Trump Organization shared a computer server with Alpha Bank, a Russian bank allegedly connected to the Kremlin.

In 2019, then Attorney General Bill Barr appointed U.S. Attorney John Durham to investigate the origins of the conspiracy that has come to be known as “Russiagate.” Russiagate is a catchword that describes an apparent conspiracy of the FBI, Clinton’s campaign, the Justice Department and the media to demonize Trump and his advisors as Russian agents. The allegations first surfaced in the months before the 2016 election.

Shortly after Trump entered office, the allegations reached a fever pitch. The media was pounding out the claims around the clock. FBI director James Comey legitimized them. Under duress, Trump’s Attorney General Jeff Sessions recused himself from handling the allegations and his deputy Rod Rosenstein, a friend of the heads of the FBI and Obama appointees at the Justice Department, appointed their friend former FBI director Robert Mueller to serve as a Special Counsel to investigate the allegations the Trump-Russia charges.

Mueller’s team of Clinton-supporting investigator fed the media a steady diet of unlawful leaks which dominated the public discourse in Washington for the first two years of Trump’s presidency. The allegation that Trump was illegitimate and a Russian agent paralyzed his presidency. Trump was unable to develop normal or constructive ties with Russia. And his ability to forge policy more generally was compromised and challenged and every turn.

And yet, during the same period, Congressional investigators discovered the truth. The allegations, including Sussmann’s to Baker, were total fabrications that originated in Clinton’s campaign. The Clinton campaign and the Democrat Party paid Perkins Coie tens of millions of dollars which they pocketed and doled out to private investigators, cyberwarfare experts and opposition research firms to concoct false allegations about Trump and his advisors and then peddle them to the FBI, the Justice Department and the supportive media.

In March 2019, Mueller finally ended his investigation. Despite the leaks, and efforts to obfuscate the truth, the report concluded that there was no evidence Trump or his advisors had colluded with the Russians during the 2016 campaign.

Barr appointed Durham shortly after Mueller submitted his report. Sussmann was the first person involved in the anti-Trump conspiracy to stand trial.

Durham had clear evidence that Sussmann lied to the FBI. Sussmann told Baker that he was bringing the Alpha Bank allegations as a private citizen, rather than as a campaign lawyer. To avoid conviction, Sussmann said that his was not material for the FBI’s operations. To substantiate his claim, Sussmann’s attorneys revealed that throughout the campaign, Sussmann was acting in full partnership with the FBI leadership. Among other things, Sussmann’s attorneys revealed that after his meeting with Baker, the FBI field agent who investigated his allegations about the Trump Organization and Alpha Bank concluded that the story was utter nonsense and asked to investigate the source of the claim. The FBI’s leadership not only ignored his request, they kept the investigation open and moved it to FBI headquarters. Sussmann himself had a badge that gave him free access to the FBI building. He was so close to the FBI leadership that they asked him to edit FBI press releases related to the Democrat party’s allegation that their computer was hacked by Russia. 

As if all this were insufficient, shortly after Sussmann’s acquittal, a whistleblower at Perkins Coie told two Republican congressmen that since 2012, the FBI has operated a secure facility inside Perkins Coie law offices. And until his departure from the firm last year, Sussmann operated the facility. The implication — that the FBI has effectively been merged with the Democrat Party since 2012 by Perkins Coie – is jaw dropping.

One of the keys to understanding the Russiagate conspiracy is that it wasn’t only the FBI that operated as one with the Democrat Party. The media was also a full partner. It was a circular operation. Campaign operatives like Sussmann farmed false allegations to the FBI to convince it to open investigations. Then they farmed the same fables to the Washington press corps and used the fact that the FBI was also looking into the allegations to convince the reporters to publish the allegations. They then used the media stories to persuade the FBI to keep investigating.

And again, the investigations went on and morphed into the Mueller probe and 24/7 media drumbeat of prejudicial leaks that paralyzed the Trump presidency. All along, all parties involved knew that the allegations against Trump and his advisors were false and originated from the Clinton campaign and the Democrat Party.

Looking at the Sussmann trial from Israel it is impossible not to draw parallels to former prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s trial. In both cases, a politicized legal fraternity colluded with the media to prevent the electoral victory of their political opponent. And in both cases, the media was a full partner in the scheme.

Netanyahu is standing trial for bribery and breach of trust. The “breach of trust” charge is a subjective catch-all concept that the prosecutors admit wouldn’t have sufficed on its own to bring Netanyahu to trial. The bribery charge was the key to Netanyahu’s political downfall.

Netanyahu’s trial opened last April. Last May he was ousted from office. To date, some 15 prosecution witnesses have taken the stand and one by one, they have not merely demolished every aspect of the prosecution’s charges against Netanyahu, they have exposed the full partnership of police investigators and state prosecutions in their joint mission to “get Netanyahu,” that is, to oust him from power, at all costs.

To achieve their political goal, the police descended on Netanyahu’s advisors one by one and gave them the treatment generally reserved for terrorists and violent criminals. They were dragged from their beds at dawn before their families and carted off to investigation rooms and flea-ridden jail cells. They were denied food. They were subjected to public humiliation in the media. Their electronic communications were illegally tapped. Their families were threatened. Their livelihoods were destroyed.

And the police didn’t let them go until they gave them something – anything – to incriminate the Prime Minister of Israel.  

Since Netanyahu had committed no crime, then attorney general Avichai Mandelblit and state prosecutor Shai Nitzan reinvented the bribery statute to claim that lawful actions Netanyahu did undertake were criminal.

Like every politician on the face of the planet, Netanyahu sought positive coverage from news organizations. The prosecution decided that this effort amounted to a solicitation of a bribe. Netanyahu signed regulatory decisions that affected a telecommunications firm owned by his friend. The prosecution decided this was a favor – a payment for positive coverage from his friend’s news website. Unfortunately for the prosecution, Netanyahu received terrible coverage from the website. But no matter, the prosecutors simply updated the definition of bribery. They said Netanyahu received “undo responsiveness” from the website’s management to his requests for better coverage, and that was now the definition of a bribe.

Over the first several months of the trial, prosecution witness after prosecution witness shred the claim. The website’s management was not responsive to requests from Netanyahu or his spokesmen, not in absolute terms and not in comparison to requests from other politicians.

Over the past three months, the focus of the trial moved to the alleged regulatory favors Netanyahu provided his friend, who owned the telecommunications giant Bezeq along with his website. Here too, the prosecution’s case has fallen apart. Netanyahu was a mere rubber stamp in the regulatory process. He gave no instructions to his underlings. There was no give, and no take. There was no bribe.  

There are many different ways to view the prosecution’s behavior. Some commentators argue that they never thought that Netanyahu would risk going to trial and would simply cop a plea to avoid prison and slink off into the shadows, handing leadership of the country to someone else. Others claim that the prosecutors are simply stupid, or incompetent.

But judging from their behavior, Israel’s legal fraternity was – and remains – rabidly political. They used every power they could conjure up to bring about Netanyahu’s downfall. They invented laws just for him. They defined politics and journalism as criminal enterprises, to criminalize Netanyahu’s non-criminal actions – which it works out, he didn’t even undertake. They trampled the very notion of the rule of law in their “ends justify the mean” campaign to force Netanyahu from power.

And just as in the case of Russiagate, the prosecutors and the police could never have conducted their legal coup d’etat without the media’s full cooperation. Just as was the case with Trump and the U.S. media, so in Netanyahu’s case, the Israeli media was a full partner in the plot to overthrow Netanyahu. Throughout the two-year investigation, the media received a constant stream of illegal, and grossly distorted information from police interrogations which carefully selected reporters breathlessly reported daily on the evening news.

Israel’s prosecutors tied their actions to the elections calendar to tilt the results against Netanyahu. And they succeeded. For four years, then attorney general Mandelblit was the most powerful “politician” in Israel. And he won. Netanyahu was first paralyzed and weakened by the investigations, then critically wounded by the indictment, and finally forced from office.

Whether or not Netanyahu is exonerated, whether or not Sussmann’s acquittal was justified, the fact is that no verdict will bring justice or bridge the divides in American and Israeli societies. So long as the legal systems that created Russiagate and ousted Netanyahu from power remain corrupted by politicized bureaucrats, our societies will only grow more divided and unstable.

Originally published in Israel Hayom.

 

Caroline Glick

Source: https://carolineglick.com/from-washington-to-jerusalem-the-conspiracies-are-unravelling/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Out of Baby Formula - John Stossel

by John Stossel

The real reason for the shortage.

 


Parents still struggle to find baby formula.

The left and most media (sorry, same thing?) blame "corporate power run amok." House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says, "There might be a need for indictment!"

They blame Abbott Laboratories, because it shut down a Similac plant. The Food and Drug Administration says unsanitary conditions led to deaths of two infants, but Abbott denies that its formula recall had anything to do with those deaths.

In any case, one factory closure doesn't normally cause massive shortages.

My new video gives the real reason for the formula shortage.

First: bans on imports. There's plenty of formula on supermarket shelves in Mexico and Europe. Normally, American companies would just buy that and ship it here.

But they can't, because of several destructive government policies.

"The dairy industry in the United States has a really long history of lobbying the government and achieving protection," explains Cato Institute trade policy specialist Scott Lincicome.

That "protection" includes fat tariffs on formula from overseas and outright bans by the FDA.

There was a gray market where people were getting around these rules. "American parents enlisted third-party sellers to obtain European infant formula," says Lincicome.

Boxes of formula arrived, but customs won't let American parents have it. They've "been seizing European baby formula shipments at the border, much like a drug seizure," says Lincicome.

Why are imports banned? For safety, says the government, but formula is often banned for stupid bureaucratic reasons.

"If you have the wrong scooper, banned!" says Lincicome. "If you don't list a certain ingredient that the FDA demands, you're banned!" If ingredients are listed in the "wrong" order or aren't listed in English, the food is banned "even if a third-party retailer provides you with the English translation."

I say to Lincicome, "I would think that government now would suspend those rules."

"It certainly should," he replies. "But the dairy industry lobbied very hard for these rules that provided them essentially a captive market. They're not going to give that up easily."

Because of the shortage, our government has now approved imports from one British company. They also launched "Operation Fly Formula," which flies formula here in military planes.

But these responses are pathetic. They pick up only the few bottles made in FDA-approved facilities, and then they waste time re-inspecting it on arrival.

"They want make sure the formula is safe," I say to Lincicome.

"A legitimate concern if it were infant formula from China," he replies. "But the largest producer of formula is in Europe.

Maybe the European product isn't as safe.

"It is!" says Lincicome. "It's exported all over the world." But we can't have it because "the FDA is extremely jealous of its regulatory authority."

Another reason for the shortage is government limits on competition.

Abbott Nutrition grabbed most of that market by offering government the lowest price. Good for them. But after Abbott's recall, there were few alternatives for parents to turn to.

"It's going to take weeks for Abbott to get manufacturing up and running again because they're going to need FDA clearance," says Lincicome. "The time for fixing this was months before the crisis hit, because now we have a highly concentrated domestic market (and) a tariff and regulatory wall around the country."

Much of what government does involves trying to fix things government messed up in the first place.

But politicians rarely admit that. They blame business.

On the floor of Congress, big government lovers like Connecticut's Rep. Rosa DeLauro complain about "corporate greed" and demand the FDA be given more money. "The usual suspects blame capitalism and greedy corporations," says Lincicome. "Clearly it's government policy that's causing the biggest problems."

 

John Stossel

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/out-baby-formula-john-stossel/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Mark Levin knocked it out of the park Sunday - Thomas Lifson

 

​ by Thomas Lifson

[O]ne short sentence that he uttered is staying with me, probably for the rest of my life: “The state is devouring civil society.”

Introducing the June 5, 2022 edition of his Fox News program “Life, Liberty and Levin,” Mark Levin stated, “This may be the most important opening statement I’ve ever made on this program or maybe any other program.”

I tend to agree.

Mark is the rarest of commentators: a rock-solid scholar – a teacher -- who is also a spirited and gifted polemicist, able to take complex issues of the Constitution and bring them to bear on the issues of the day.

The focus was the horrific school shooting in Uvalde, with mention also of Buffalo, but as he does so well, Mark placed these atrocities in the context of the ruling class and what it is attempting to do to our Constitution.

I won’t attempt to summarize. The entire segment is less than 13 minutes, and it is worth every second of your time. But one short sentence that he uttered is staying with me, probably for the rest of my life: “The state is devouring civil society.”

Watch and learn:

Photo credit: YouTube screengrab

 

Thomas Lifson

Source: https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2022/06/mark_levin_knocked_it_out_of_the_park_sunday.html

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

NATO Should NOT Pay Ransom to Turkey; Instead, Should Amend Rules to Expel It - Burak Bekdil

 

by Burak Bekdil

"[G]iving in to Ankara's demands amounts to letting an autocrat design the security architecture of Europe and shape the future of the Western system." — Cengiz Çandar, journalist, Al-Monitor, May 24, 2022.

Translations of this item:

  • "Turkey is a member of NATO, but under Mr. Erdoğan, it no longer subscribes to the values that underpin this great alliance. Article 13 of the NATO charter provides a mechanism for members to withdraw. Perhaps it is time to amend Article 13 to establish a procedure for the expulsion of a member nation." — Former US Senator Joe Lieberman and Mark D. Wallace, Wall Street Journal, May 18, 2022.

  • "[G]iving in to Ankara's demands amounts to letting an autocrat design the security architecture of Europe and shape the future of the Western system." — Cengiz Çandar, journalist, Al-Monitor, May 24, 2022.

  • With its $8,000 per capita GDP, Erdoğan's ailing Turkey is not more powerful than the other 29 NATO allies combined. NATO's political leaders must stop acting as if it is.

In a historic move, Sweden and Finland recently submitted their written applications to join NATO but Turkey's Islamist strongman, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan (pictured), is threatening to use his country's veto power to block the Nordic nations coming under the Western security umbrella. This is putting NATO's renewed credibility at stake, presumably to the delight of NATO's nemesis, Russian President Vladimir Putin. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images)

Just when, after years of idling around, NATO appears to be gaining some strategic prominence following Russia's invasion of Ukraine, the only Muslim member of the alliance is holding 29 other members as hostage, blocking the most critical move in its history. Surrendering to an Islamist's well-known oriental bargaining tactics will mean the demise of the alliance.

In a historic move, Sweden and Finland recently submitted their written applications to join NATO but Turkey's Islamist strongman, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, is threatening to use his country's veto power to block the Nordic nations coming under the Western security umbrella. This is putting NATO's renewed credibility at stake, presumably to the delight of NATO's nemesis, Russian President Vladimir Putin.

On May 25, senior Swedish and Finnish delegations arrived in Ankara to meet with Erdoğan's spokesman, Ibrahim Kalın, and deputy foreign minister Sedat Önal, with a mission to overcome Turkey's objections. Every single diplomat in the Turkish capital knew that the mission would fail before it even took off.

"We stated that this procedure [Sweden and Finland joining NATO] would not be possible until Turkey's security concerns were addressed," Kalın told the media after the meeting. But what are Turkey's security concerns, and why are they related to two small European Union nations, one with a 1,300 km (810 mile) border with Russia?

Officially speaking, Turkey demands "written agreement" from Finland and Sweden for steps to end their "support for terrorism" -- meaning their alleged logistical and political support for the PKK Kurdish insurgents and their YPG branch in Syria. It accuses the two countries of harboring members of the "Gülen movement," which Ankara alleges was behind a failed military coup attempt in 2016. Furthermore, Ankara demands that Sweden and Finland end the ban on exporting weapons to Turkey, which they imposed after Turkey's military incursion into northeast Syria in 2019.

Ankara said that it has requested the extradition of Kurdish fighters and other suspects since 2017 but has not received a positive response from Stockholm. The Turkish government claimed that Sweden has decided to provide $376 million to support Kurdish fighters in 2023 and that it has provided them with military equipment, including anti-tank weapons and drones. Sweden denies these accusations.

Erdoğan seems to think that he has found a golden opportunity to blackmail the entire Western alliance, and get the maximum out of a list of official and unofficial demands. Erdoğan also seems to be hoping to reset Turkey's badly strained ties with the West, most notably with the U.S. He appears to want a new, warm political welcome back into the Western world, along with a narrative to Turkey's anti-Western masses of how he brought the evil West to its knees -- always a sure vote-catcher in xenophobic Turkey. He badly needs that Western appeasement for his campaign for re-election in June 2023. Turkey's economy, with an annual inflation rate of 70%, is in doldrums to put it mildly.

What else does Erdoğan want? He will start negotiating a return to the US-led F-35 fighter jet program, from which Turkey was expelled after it acquired the Russian-made S-400 surface-to-air defense system. If re-joining the multinational program to manufacture the world's most advanced fighter jet is not possible, Erdoğan will bargain for U.S. approval to buy a batch of 40 F-16 Block 70 aircraft and upgrade kits for 80 more jets.

Erdoğan's foreign policy team will make the process of entering NATO as hard as possible for Sweden and Finland. "It is not an easy process," a senior Turkish official told Reuters adding that Sweden and Finland must take "difficult" steps to win Ankara's support. "Further negotiations will continue. But a date doesn't seem very close."

All 29 other NATO allies want to seal Sweden and Finland's membership before the NATO Summit in Madrid on June 29-30. After a meeting in Washington with U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, Finnish Foreign Minister Pekka Haavisto said it was extremely important that results be achieved before the Madrid summit. Raising the stakes in this poker game, however, Turkish officials downplayed prospects of reaching an agreement before the summit.

Unlike independent observers, some Western leaders are downplaying the "Turkish problem." NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg, for instance, wrote on Twitter that he and Erdoğan "agree that the security concerns of all Allies must be taken into account and talks need to continue to find a solution."

When asked if he could assuage Turkish concerns, U.S. President Joe Biden said, "I'm not going to Turkey, but I think we're going to be OK."

Echoing similar optimism, National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan said:

"We're confident that, at the end of the day, Finland and Sweden will have an effective and efficient accession process, that Turkey's concerns can be addressed. We feel very good about where this will track to."

Erdoğan's blackmailing tactics risk fueling a debate within NATO about Turkey's fitness to remain an ally. "Does Erdoğan's Turkey Belong in NATO?" asked former US Senator Joe Lieberman and Mark D. Wallace, a U.S. Ambassador to the UN for Management and Reform, in an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal. They noted that unlike Finland and Sweden, Turkey would not meet NATO's democracy requirements if it were applying for membership today. According to Lieberman and Wallace:

"Turkey is a member of NATO, but under Mr. Erdoğan, it no longer subscribes to the values that underpin this great alliance. Article 13 of the NATO charter provides a mechanism for members to withdraw. Perhaps it is time to amend Article 13 to establish a procedure for the expulsion of a member nation."

Adding to that, Turkish journalist and analyst Cengiz Candar cautioned:

"Giving in to Ankara's demands amounts to letting an autocrat design the security architecture of Europe and shape the future of the Western system."

With its $8,000 per capita GDP, Erdoğan's ailing Turkey is not more powerful than the other 29 NATO allies combined. NATO's political leaders must stop acting as if it is.

 

Burak Bekdill, one of Turkey's leading journalists, was recently fired from the country's most noted newspaper after 29 years, for writing in Gatestone what is taking place in Turkey. He is a Fellow at the Middle East Forum.

Source: https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/18586/nato-expel-turkey

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

SOS: Is The Pentagon Losing the U.S. to China? - Judith Bergman

 

by Judith Bergman

From drone swarming to anti-satellite weapons programs, Russia and the PRC have studied our capabilities carefully and are rapidly modernizing its own military capabilities with a priority both on asymmetry designed to neutralize U.S. overmatch and accessing innovations in its commercial sector

  • "We have no competing fighting chance against China in 15 to 20 years. Right now, it's already a done deal; it is already over in my opinion." — Nicolas Chaillan, former first Chief Software Officer for the Air Force, who resigned in protest over the Pentagon's slow pace of technological development, citing China's fast advancements in artificial intelligence, machine learning, and general capabilities in cybersecurity, Financial Times, October 10, 2021

  • "By the time the Government manages to produce something, it's too often obsolete." — Preston Dunlap, the Pentagon's first Chief Architect Officer, responsible for promoting technological innovation at the Pentagon, who also resigned, labelling the Pentagon "the world's largest bureaucracy;" The Japan Times, April 19, 2022.

  • "Our lack of adopting these [commercial innovations] quickly creates an asymmetric disadvantage if our adversaries adopt them more rapidly... These differences are extremely relevant for conflicts we may face in the next decade where our adversaries effectively employ commercial technologies. For example, when U.S. troops were stationed in Iraq, ISIS sent small drones, which can be purchased on e-commerce platforms like Amazon, with grenades to kill American soldiers in Mosul... The DoD must add new capabilities like these in 1-2 years rather than 1-2 decades." — Michael Brown, Director of the Defense Innovation Unit at the Pentagon, testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee, April 6, 2022.

  • "[In the PRC and Russia], private companies... work together closely with their militaries to gain experience with new technologies and concepts. From drone swarming to anti-satellite weapons programs, Russia and the PRC have studied our capabilities carefully and are rapidly modernizing its own military capabilities with a priority both on asymmetry designed to neutralize U.S. overmatch and accessing innovations in its commercial sector... Imagine how well our forces will defend against PLA swarms of drones if we have not experimented with this concept," — Michael Brown, testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee, April 6, 2022.

  • "The current sequential process lags commercial product cycles and delivers technology several generations behind which would be the equivalent of supplying flip-phones and fax machines to our warfighters today..." — Michael Brown, testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee, April 6, 2022.

The US Defense Department's current outdated and slow approach to technological innovation could eventually lead China to overtake the US in areas such as artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, and space. Pictured: A showcase of artificial intelligence usages at the 14th China International Exhibition on Public Safety and Security at the China International Exhibition Center in Beijing, China on October 24, 2018. (Photo by Nicolas Asfouri/AFP via Getty Images)

Last July, the director of the Central Intelligence Agency, William J. Burns, said that China is "the single biggest geopolitical challenge that the United States faces far out into the 21st century" and that "the main arena for competition and rivalry with China" is technology.

The Pentagon has been facing massive criticism for being unable properly, if at all, to meet that very technological challenge. "The U.S. government is not prepared to defend the United States in the coming artificial intelligence (AI) era," the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence warned in March 2021, while also saying that China was on its way to become the world's top AI superpower.

In October 2021, a senior cybersecurity official at the Pentagon, Nicolas Chaillan, who was the first Chief Software Officer for the Air Force, resigned in protest over the Pentagon's slow pace of technological development. "We have no competing fighting chance against China in 15 to 20 years. Right now, it's already a done deal; it is already over in my opinion" Chaillan said, citing China's fast advancements in artificial intelligence, machine learning, and general capabilities in cybersecurity. "Whether it takes a war or not is kind of anecdotal."

"I realized pretty quickly, we're very behind in cyber, to a point that it was very scary when it comes to critical infrastructure and the lack of security," Chaillan said in August 2021. "And we see it every day, more and more, and I still don't believe we have any kind of handle on what's going on."

In April, another senior official, Preston Dunlap, the Pentagon's first Chief Architect Officer, responsible for promoting technological innovation at the Pentagon, also resigned. In a nine-page resignation statement, Dunlap made it clear that the Pentagon, which Dunlap labeled "the world's largest bureaucracy", was far behind the American domestic commercial sector in data, distributed computer processing, software, AI and cybersecurity and that it badly needed "structural change."

"By the time the Government manages to produce something, it's too often obsolete," he wrote. "Much more must be done if DoD is going to regrow its thinning technological edge." Additionally, Dunlap pointed out that the Pentagon would have to stop focusing on internal turf wars and "reinventing the wheel" and work together with the private sector.

In this, he echoed Nicolas Chaillan, who also pointed out that the Pentagon suffers from "silo thinking" where different agencies work on the same tasks and do not share information. "We have silos within silos," Chaillan said.

"We have people reinventing the wheel, whether for good reasons or bad reasons, whether it's ego-driven or for little kingdom-building exercises... we need to start having a cohesive cybersecurity and IT capability stack."

Also in April, another outgoing official, David Spirk, the Pentagon's Chief Data Officer, said that the organization would have to accelerate efforts to counter adversaries developing military tools based on modern technologies.

The concerns do not only come from resigning DoD officials but also from high-ranking current officials.

"In an era where the PRC has stolen plans for our exquisite weapons platforms and carefully studied our way of fighting, advances in commercial technology offer a unique opportunity to achieve surprise rapidly," Director of the Defense Innovation Unit at the Pentagon, Michael Brown, said in testimony before the Senate Armed Services Committee on April 6.

"Despite its importance, the Pentagon does not currently have a systematic or effective approach to rapidly access and leverage commercial technologies at scale."

Brown went on to say that 11 of the 14 critical technologies for national security are commercial and that the absence of an effective approach for the military to rapidly adopt commercial technology, such as advanced communications, AI software, small drones, synthetic aperture radar (SAR) satellite imagery and many others, represents a "glaring weakness". There is little difference in those commercial technologies from strictly defense technologies, and the Department of Defense (DoD) needs to "move much faster in assessing and fielding these technologies". The Pentagon, in other words, does not adopt the immense advances made in the commercial sector for the benefit of the military broadly or fast enough and that puts the US at a serious disadvantage compared to adversaries such as China.

"Since DoD does not control the global diffusion of these technologies, our lack of adopting these quickly creates an asymmetric disadvantage if our adversaries adopt them more rapidly," Brown said.

"These differences are extremely relevant for conflicts we may face in the next decade where our adversaries effectively employ commercial technologies. For example, when U.S. troops were stationed in Iraq, ISIS sent small drones, which can be purchased on e-commerce platforms like Amazon, with grenades to kill American soldiers in Mosul... The DoD must add new capabilities like these in 1-2 years rather than 1-2 decades."

Brown delivered more damning testimony, when he detailed how much the DoD lags behind:

"The current sequential process lags commercial product cycles and delivers technology several generations behind which would be the equivalent of supplying flip-phones and fax machines to our warfighters today... While the Pentagon prides itself on following voluminous and well-specified DoD processes, the result is that in commercially advanced technologies such as advanced communications, artificial intelligence and machine learning, cyber and autonomous systems, we will be placing outdated, overpriced technology in the hands of our warfighters... DoD has not yet established a complementary process to the one Secretary McNamara put in place in the 1960s for defense technologies... At DoD, we continue in a 'business as usual' fashion at our peril."

By comparison, Brown made it clear that:

"The PRC and Russia compel their private companies to work together closely with their militaries to gain experience with new technologies and concepts. From drone swarming to anti-satellite weapons programs, Russia and the PRC have studied our capabilities carefully and are rapidly modernizing its own military capabilities with a priority both on asymmetry designed to neutralize U.S. overmatch and accessing innovations in its commercial sector...

"Imagine how well our forces will defend against PLA swarms of drones if we have not experimented with this concept... Imagine if we do not support more non-traditional suppliers of satellites or quantum sensors such that these technologies do not remain competitive in the U.S. and go the way of solar panels or small drones—controlled by the PRC."

There are also concerns about a widespread sense of risk-aversion in the Pentagon. Deputy Secretary of Defense Kathleen Hicks, also in April, warned that risk-aversion is standing in the way of technological innovation.

"Innovation is slowed down by resistance to technological risk, especially for hypersonic weapon programs, Hicks told Defense Writers Group reporters in Washington, D.C. The United States used to be first class in its approach to innovation, which necessitated a willingness to fail during tests, she said."

China tested its first hypersonic missile last summer. In March, Russia said that it had used a hypersonic missile, known as the Kinzhal, in Ukraine for the first time.

According to Hicks:

"What we see in general is a real resistance to that approach and concern over whether the U.S. investments are making a difference up on Capitol Hill, and so you get curtailment of programs, you get concerns over concurrency""

The current outdated and slow approach to technological innovation could eventually lead China to overtake the US in space, among other areas. NASA, for instance, has spent more than $23 billion to build the single-use Space Launch System (SLS), as a replacement for its Space Shuttle program. Announced back in 2010, the project has been delayed by more than five years so far and is already obsolete, in addition to being, at $4.1 billion per launch, almost prohibitively expensive to deploy. By comparison, China has been advancing in space by copying the commercial space sector, specifically the American one. The Long March 2C rocket that China launched in the summer of 2019 for the first time had parts -- the grid fins -- that were "virtually identical" to those that are used to steer the SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket. A year after that test, according to Eric Berger, senior space editor at Ars Technica, "China's main space contractor revealed plans to develop the ability to reuse its Long March 8 booster, which is powered by kerosene fuel, the same type of power that fuels SpaceX rockets. By 2025, Chinese officials said, this rocket would be capable of landing on a sea platform, like SpaceX's Falcon 9 booster does.

 

Judith Bergman, a columnist, lawyer and political analyst, is a Distinguished Senior Fellow at Gatestone Institute.

Source: https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/18512/pentagon-losing-to-china

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Jerusalem District Court Reimposes Prohibition on Jewish Prayer at Temple Mount - Hugh Fitzgerald

 

​ by Hugh Fitzgerald

Caving in to Arab threats in order to “safeguard the public order.”

 


In 1967, Israel’s Minister of Defense Moshe Dayan made a fateful decision. Just after Israel, through force of arms, took possession of east Jerusalem, including the Old City and the Temple Mount, Dayan declared that Jewish visitors to the Mount would not be allowed to pray, either aloud or silently, at the site. You read that right: At the holiest site in Judaism, Jews would not be allowed to pray. Dayan, himself completely secular and insufficiently appreciative of the rights of religious Jews, thought that such a prohibition would be a way of winning favor with the Arabs. Fifty-five years later, we see that it did not. Instead, at that point in time, when the Arabs were still reeling from their defeat, Dayan could have insisted that “at Temple Mount both Muslims and Jews will have their rights to pray guaranteed,” and the Arabs would have had to accept it. And the world, not then poisoned with anti-Israel sentiments, would have applauded: Freedom of religion for everyone. Who, except for the Arabs and Muslims, could object? In June of 1967, when support for Israel in the Western world was at its zenith, no one.

Over the last few years, the Israeli police on the Temple Mount, who are charged with the task of preventing Jews from praying, have loosened up a bit on their rigorous enforcement of the prohibition. They have begun to allow — by looking the other way — Jews to mouth silent prayers. And just weeks ago, three Israeli boys wanting to challenge the prohibition, said the “Shema” prayer aloud on the Temple Mount and then bowed, before the police took them away and charged them with violating the prohibition. The presiding judge at the Jerusalem Magistrate’s Court decided in favor of the boys, and against the Israeli enforcement of that longstanding prohibition on Jewish prayer.

The Arabs then erupted in fury, threating all kinds of violence, and accusing Israel of, inter alia, planning to take over the Al-Aqsa Mosque and turning it into a synagogue. In other words, the Israelis were faced with the unhinged anger of Palestinians and Israeli Arabs. The Israeli government promptly appealed the decision, and the Jerusalem District Court reversed the lower court’s decision, not out of any appeal to justice – justice would have demanded, rather, that Jews should be allowed to say prayers at the holiest site in Judaism – but only in order to avoid the violence that the Arabs threatened would be the result if Jews started praying aloud on the Temple Mount.

The full report on the Israeli court’s decision is here: “Israeli Appeal Court Quashes Ruling on Jewish Prayer at Temple Mount,” Algemeiner, May 25, 2022:

…Three Jewish youths who received a restraining order after praying at the site successfully challenged the police decision at Jerusalem Magistrates Court, which ruled on Sunday that their actions had not constituted a breach of the peace.

That prompted protests from the Palestinian leadership, threats from Palestinian militants and a pledge from Israel that the status quo would be preserved.

The state filed a counter-appeal on Wednesday with Jerusalem District Court, which found in favor after nightfall.

“The special sensitivity of the Temple Mount cannot be overstated,” Judge Einat Avman-Moller said in her ruling.

A right to freedom of Jewish worship there “is not absolute, and should be superseded by other interests, among them the safeguarding of public order,” she said.

In other words, whenever Arabs offer a credible threat of violence, their wishes must be respected in order to “safeguard the public order.” This is the so-called “heckler’s veto” on stilts. 

In a statement to Reuters before Wednesday’s ruling, Nati Rom, a lawyer for the defendants, said: “It is strange and regrettable that, in the 21st century, in a Jewish and democratic country, the basic human rights of Jews would be so harmed.”…

“Strange and regrettable” indeed, that in the Jewish state, while Muslims on the Mount – sometimes numbering in the hundreds of thousands – can pray at any time and on any day, inside Al-Aqsa and on the 35-acre Al-Aqsa Compound –Jewish visitors on the Mount can visit only during four hours each day, and only on five days in the week and what is far worse, are prohibited from saying prayers at the holiest site in Judaism, lest Muslims be offended.

The overturning of the Jerusalem Magistrate Court’s ruling that gave Jews the right to pray is one more example of that weakness of Israeli leaders, who keep thinking that they can satisfy the Arabs by showing good will, by bending over backwards, by not doing anything to annoy them. It doesn’t work. The Arabs pocket every Israeli concession as theirs by right. Dayan’s fateful ruling in 1967, prohibiting Jews from praying on the Temple Mount, has prevented the exercise of religious freedom by Jews alone, and done nothing to mollify the Arabs. So Dayan’s 1967 Temple Mount Mistake still stands. What will it take, one wonders, how many more years of Israel yielding on the rules applied to the Temple Mount must pass, until the prohibition on Jewish prayer is finally revoked?

 

Hugh Fitzgerald

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/jerusalem-district-court-reimposes-prohibition-hugh-fitzgerald/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Erdogan Plans Land Seizure In Northern Syria - Hugh Fitzgerald

 

​ by Hugh Fitzgerald

Violating Syrian sovereignty to crush the Kurds.

 


Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the neo-Ottomanist president of Turkey, who sits plotting and planning in his 1,150 room Ak Saray, or White Palace, is mischief-making again. Now he has announced that Turkish troops will be occupying a 30-kilometer-deep stretch along the Turkish border with northern Syria. The troops will remain for as long as Turkey deems there to be a credible threat from Kurds in the neighborhood. That is likely to be a very long time. It is, however, a greatly exaggerated worry. The Kurds in Syria are no real threat to Erdogan; most of them have already moved away from the border, so as to avoid clashes with Turkish soldiers. Erdogan is determined that the several million Kurds in Syria do not join forces with the fifteen million Kurds in Turkey, especially those Turkish Kurds who are members of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party, or PKK, that has been designated by Turkey, the U.S., and the EU, as a terrorist organization. But the PKK has only 5,000 members. How much of a threat can the PKK be to the Turkish army, with its 355,000 active troops? In order to be even more secure, Erdogan plans to carve out of northern Syria a cordon sanitaire, where Turkish troops will remain and Ankara’s writ will run. Naturally Bashar Assad, who has fought for eleven years to regain control of Syria, is furious at this latest act of territorial aggrandizement, at Syria’s expense, by Erdogan.
 
A report on Erdogan’s plans for Syria, and the Syrian response, is here: “Syria says any Turkish incursion amounts to ‘war crimes,'” Reuters, May 25, 2022 
Syria’s foreign ministry said on Wednesday that it would consider any Turkish military incursions into its territory as “war crimes and crimes against humanity.”
Comment:
This is rich, coming from the foreign ministry of Bashar Assad’s Syria. Assad’s regime has murdered more than 600,000 civilians in the course of its civil war; it has used chemical weapons – chlorine gas, sarin, and sulfur mustard gas –on its enemies; the trustworthy Syrian Observatory for Human Rights has provided evidence that over 47,000 civilians were killed under torture in the detention centers and prisons of Assad’s regime. How dare the Assad regime accuse Turkey of “war crimes”?
Turkish President Tayyip Erdogan on Monday [May 24] said Ankara would soon create safe zones 30 km (20 miles) beyond its southern borders to combat what he characterized as terrorist threats, in a likely reference to Kurdish armed groups in northern Syria.
Hmmm. A “terrorist threat” from Syrian Kurds, according to Recep Tayyip Erdogan, justifies occupying a “safe zone” 20 miles deep. Why, then, does he rant against Israel for wanting to keep control of its own “safe zone” in the West Bank, which is only 30 miles wide?
Ankara has already conducted three incursions into northern Syria since 2016, mainly targeting the US-backed Syrian Kurdish YPG.
Has the Kurdish YPG shot thousands of rockets into Turkey, as Hamas has done from Gaza into Israel? No, not a single rocket nor missile. Do YPG operatives build terror tunnels into Turkey, or by other routes smuggle themselves across the border, in order to murder Turks, by blowing up pizza parlors, buses, and schools, as Arab terrorists from Hamas, the PIJ, and the PFLP have done over many decades to Israeli men, women, and children? Not one. Perhaps the next time Erdogan lectures the Israelis on their need to stop their “incursions” against Palestinians in Gaza or in Arab cities in the West Bank, Israeli leaders can remind him of his incursions into Syria against the YPG, with far less justification, and his seizing a large swathe of Syrian territory in order to deal with an incomparably lesser threat to his country’s security than are Hamas and its fellow Palestinian terrorists, to the security of the Jewish state.
Damascus sees the incursions as a violation of the country’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.
On Wednesday, Syria’s foreign ministry said it had sent a letter to the United Nations secretary-general and the Security Council, describing Turkey’s actions as illegitimate.
“They amount to what can be described as war crimes and crimes against humanity,” it said in a statement carried by the state news agency.
Turkey’s proposed seizure of territory in order to fend off a largely imaginary threat from the Kurds is indeed a “violation of Syria’s sovereignty and territorial integrity.” But that is very far from constituting either a “war crime” or a “crime against humanity.” If Turkey rounds up Syrian Kurds and puts them in camps, or otherwise harms them, for example by shooting non-combatants, those acts would constitute “war crimes.” Simply seizing and holding the territory where the Syrian Kurds have historically lived, and where some still live, falls far short of that designation.
 
But it will be instructive to have Turkey and Syria, both led by repressive despots who do not brook dissent, go at each other hammer-and-tongs at the U.N., whether at the General Assembly or the Security Council. The Turkish ambassador will respond to Syria’s complaint, just made to the Security Council, about Ankara’s “war crimes,” by detailing the real “war crimes” that Bashar Assad has committed during the more than 11 years of civil war, especially the torture and mass execution of civilians who supported the revolt, and the use of chemical weapons to kill tens of thousands of Syrians. Let Turkey hold up for the world pictures of the dead men, women, and children, the victims of the Assad’s regime use of chlorine gas, sarin, and sulfur mustard gas, beginning in 2012, with some of the largest chemical attacks occurring in Bayada, Homs December 23, 2012, in the Old City in Aleppo on July 29, 2014, and in Douma, outside Damascus, on July 4, 2018.
 
A study released in February 2019 tallied the chemical weapons attacks over the course of the Syrian civil war. At least 336 have occurred, with total civilian deaths amounting to 47,000, according to authors Tobias Schneider and Theresa Lütkefend of the Berlin-based Global Public Policy Institute. How many more such attacks have there been in the three years since?
These researchers pored over reports of chemical attacks going back to 2012, reviewing the available information on each to verify the details. They collected evidence from “Syrian and international non-governmental organizations, monitoring groups, private firms, local administrative bodies, relevant international bodies, local and international media, and the open source.”
 
What will the Syrian ambassador be able to reply in response to such charges? He’ll deny any chemical weapons attacks, but who will believe him? He may even claim that it’s all a frameup by the United States, or worse still, by the “Zionists”? Will the Syrian respond to the Turkish ambassador that he and his president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, are mere “tools” of the “Zionists”?
 
Isn’t it likely that along with his indignant denial of chemical weapons attacks the Syrian ambassador, in a tu-quoque defense, will provide details about Turkey’s long history of “war crimes” against its Kurds? He might go back almost a hundred years, to the first major Kurdish rebellion against the Turkish state. In 1925, an uprising for an independent Kurdistan, led by Shaikh Said Piran, was put down quickly, and Said and 36 of his followers were executed soon thereafter. Other large-scale Kurdish revolts occurred in Ararat and Dersim in 1930 and 1937. The British consul at Trebizond, the diplomatic post closest to Dersim, reported on the brutal and indiscriminate violence by the Turkish troops, and made an explicit comparison with the 1915 Armenian genocide. “Thousands of Kurds,” he wrote, “including women and children, were slain; others, mostly children, were thrown into the Euphrates; while thousands of others in less hostile areas, who had first been deprived of their cattle and other belongings, were deported to vilayets (provinces) in Central Anatolia. It is now stated that the Kurdish question no longer exists in Turkey.” Since then there have been five major Kurdish revolts, and each of them has been put down by the Turks with surpassing brutality. The Syrians will be delighted to recount the history not only of the Turkish troops’ “war crimes” against the Kurds, but of the Turkish attempt to wipe out the Kurdish identity, through such means as banning the Kurdish language in print and media, and even forbidding its use anywhere outside the home.
 
In the end, like two punch-drunk boxers who have managed to knock each other out, and are sprawled side-by-side in the ring, the Syrians and the Turks will have managed to leave one another publicly embarrassed, chagrinned, shamed. They both have had it coming. At the U.N. let Syria decry the Turkish invasion of its territory, and the Turks’ continuing history of brutal treatment of its own, and of Syria’s, Kurds. And let the Turks hold up for the international media the undeniable “war crimes” that the Assad regime carried out against its own people, 47,000 of whom were killed by chemical weapons. For a brief shining moment, Israel will not be the only one in the dock at the U.N. Savor that moment.

 

Hugh Fitzgerald

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/erdogan-plans-land-seizure-northern-syria-hugh-fitzgerald/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Report: Iranian attack on Israelis in Thailand thwarted - Israel National News

 

by Israel National News

Iran continues to target Israelis abroad in retaliation for assassination of senior Iranian officials.

 

Al-Quds Day rally in Tehran, Iran

Security forces in Thailand thwarted an Iranian plot to attack Israeli and western targets in the country, it was cleared for publication Monday evening, Mako News reported.

An Iranian agent, who was arrested in Indonesia with a fake Bulgarian passport, is believed to have been the mastermind behind the planned attacks. He worked with other elements to establish terrorist infrastructure and cells in Thailand. Although the attempted attack was thwarted, the Iranians continue to try to carry out attacks in Thailand and elsewhere.

Israeli security officials believe Iran is seeking to retaliate for a series of assassinations of senior Iranian officials, which have been blamed on Israel.

A travel warning remains in effect for Turkey amid reports that Iran is targeting Israelis in that country.

 

Israel National News

Source: https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/354445

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Minneapolis Becomes First Large City to Broadcast Islamic Call to Prayer Over Loudspeakers - Robert Spencer

 

by Robert Spencer

Celebrate diversity, you bigot! What could possibly go wrong?

 


Ilhan Omar is thrilled; on Friday, she retweeted a tweet celebrating the fact that the Islamic call to prayer, the adhan, has begun to be broadcast over loudspeakers in Minneapolis. According to the Associated Press, Minneapolis “became the first large city in the United States to allow the Islamic call to prayer, or adhan, to be broadcast publicly by its two dozen mosques.” AP added that “the transforming soundscape is testament to the large and increasingly visible Muslim community, which is greeting the change with both celebration and caution, lest it cause backlash.”

Yes, of course, we have to be worried about “backlash” from all those MAGA-hat-wearing bigots in Minneapolis, ready to go all Jussie Smollett on Muslims if they start praying too loudly, but back in the real world, everyone is happy about this, and full of self-congratulation for celebrating diversity so visibly and noisily. And it’s a shame to spoil the party, but when Minneapolis mosques now broadcast the Islamic call to prayer, do Minneapolis residents know exactly what is being proclaimed?

The adhan, prayed in Arabic, repeats “Allahu akbar” six times, “I testify that there is no god but Allah” three times, and “I testify that Muhammad is Allah’s prophet” twice. Dr. Gavin Ashenden, former chaplain to the British queen, who resigned his position in protest against a Qur’an reading in a Scottish church, observed that “the Muslim call to prayer is a dramatic piece of Islamic triumphalism. It proclaims Islam’s superiority over all other religions, and in so doing casts Jesus in the role of a charlatan and a liar. The Muslim god, Allah, is unknowable and has no son. Jesus was, therefore, a fraud in claiming He and the Father are one.”

Is Minneapolis really wise to broadcast repeatedly a declaration of the superiority of Islam, a faith that directs its adherents to make war against Christians and other non-Muslims and subjugate them as inferiors under the hegemony of believers (cf. Qur’an 9:29)? There are probably a few Christians left here and there in Minneapolis. In Egypt, mosques blare the Islamic call to prayer directly at churches during Christian prayers, in order to harass the Christians and proclaim the supremacy of Islam. Is any Christian in Minneapolis allowed to be concerned about this coming to his or her city, or would that simply be “Islamophobic”?

Is Minneapolis really wise to broadcast the cry “Allahu akbar,” beloved of jihad terrorists the world over? Chief 9/11 hijacker Mohammed Atta wrote this in his letter to himself before carrying out his jihad mission: “When the confrontation begins, strike like champions who do not want to go back to this world. Shout, ‘Allahu Akbar,’ because this strikes fear in the hearts of the non-believers.” This is why the Fort Hood jihad killer, Nidal Malik Hasan, shouted it as he shot thirteen Americans in November 2009, and why so many other jihadis have used it essentially as an announcement that non-Muslims are about to die.

Yusuf Abdulle of the Islamic Association of North America said of the prayer over loudspeakers: “It’s a sign that we are here.” In light of the use of so many elements of the adhan by jihad terrorists, however, this kind of reassurance “that we are here” may not be as welcome as it is to the local Muslims among others who may hear it: victims of jihad violence and those who are aware of the aggressive and supremacist nature of the call to prayer.

Meanwhile, Mowlid Ali, the imam at the Abubakar As-Saddique Islamic Center in south Minneapolis, added: “We hope that through calling the adhan in public, it would actually bring more interest from the neighbors in knowing about the religion of Islam.”

More interest in the religion of Islam would be great, if it were met with honest answers. But in Minneapolis today, such answers would likely be condemned and dismissed as “Islamophobic.” Minneapolis officials are no doubt certain that Muslim communities in the city will be grateful for the permission to broadcast the adhan, and will redouble their efforts to become loyal, productive citizens, marching together with non-Muslims in Minnesota into the glorious multicultural future. That’s the way it will work out. Isn’t it? No Muslims, not a single one, will take seriously the adhan’s declarations of Islamic superiority and heed the Qur’an’s calls to wage war against unbelievers. Right? In multiculti Minneapolis today, the idea that someone might heed the call to jihad is inconceivable!

 

Robert Spencer is the director of Jihad Watch and a Shillman Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center. He is author of 23 books including many bestsellers, such as The Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam (and the Crusades), The Truth About Muhammad and The History of Jihad. His latest book is The Critical Qur’an. Follow him on Twitter here. Like him on Facebook here.

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/minneapolis-becomes-first-large-city-broadcast-robert-spencer/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

The Octogenarian Priest Who Became Islam’s Bane - Raymond Ibrahim

 

​ by Raymond Ibrahim

Zakaria Botros, 87-years-old and still going strong.

 


What a world of difference there is between anti-Islamic polemics emanating from the secular West and those emanating from the religiously charged Arab world itself.  This is the thought I have whenever I watch Arabic language programs and debates, which tend to have an unrestrained and animated quality.

Fr. Zakaria Botros, first introduced to non-Arabic speakers in this 2008 article, is an especially appropriate case study. Originally a Coptic Christian priest from Egypt turned polemicist and evangelist, since around 2000, he has become a major thorn in Islam’s side, as evidenced by the many calls for his assassination.

Zakaria appears on a satellite channel, al-Fady TV, where he regularly takes Islam to task, primarily by asking tough questions concerning many of its most authoritative texts (e.g., Koran, hadith, sira, tafsirs, etc.) and teachings.  And I don’t mean the tough questions that we’re familiar with—for example, if Islam is a religion of peace, why is the Koran inundated with violence and intolerance?  No, he has dug into even the most arcane of Islam’s books (almost all of which have not been translated out of Arabic) and unearthed some immensely problematic revelations.

A recent episode, for example, revolved around a bizarre hadith recorded in several respected Islamic texts, including the hadith collections of Ibn Hanbal, a founder of one of Islam’s four Sunni madhhabs.  In it, Muhammad takes a companion, Abdullah bin Mas‘ud, out into the desert night.  The prophet then draws a circle in the sand and tells ibn Mas‘ud not to leave it.  Muhammad then goes off a little distance, at which point his companion and narrator of the hadith, says he saw two tall, naked men appear and go to Muhammad, whereupon “they began to ride [يركبون, which can also be translated as mount] the Messenger of Allah.”  Meanwhile, and all through the night, these strange men would also try to access Mas‘ud, who records being “terrified,” though they were prevented from crossing the circle made by Muhammad. Then, with the rising of the sun, they quickly absconded, whereupon Mas‘ud saw Muhammad approaching him, “slowly and in pain from being ridden.”   The unflattering implications were then elaborated by Fr. Zakaria.

Another episode revolved around the recent slaughter of a fellow Coptic Christian priest in Egypt, Fr. Arsenious Wadid.  In it, Fr. Zakaria sought to expose the “true terrorist” behind this crime.  It wasn’t the actual Muslim murderer, he said, nor even Muhammad himself, but rather, “the Lord of Muhammad, that is, Satan!” Thereafter, he examined Koran verse after Koran verse—dealing with deceiving, killing, plundering, and sexually enslaving women—as proof of a diabolical rather than heavenly inspiration.  As is his wont, he complemented his presentation by quoting Christian scriptures; for example, he quoted John 8:44 as foretelling of Allah and those he would deceive:

You belong to your father, the devil, and you want to carry out your father’s desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, not holding to the truth, for there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks his native language, for he is a liar and the father of lies.

Although this quick summation of episodes risks presenting them as consisting of vindictive and undocumented slanders against Islam and its prophet, in reality, during the bulk of his hour-long episodes, including the aforementioned two, Fr. Zakaria offers copious documentation: he relies almost exclusively on well-respected and authoritative Muslim sources, from al-turath al-Islami (the Islamic heritage); he methodically provides complete references to all the texts he uses, shows images of the text itself, including page number; and, finally, he challenges any and all experts in Islam to call in and correct him if he’s wrong.

Such is the dilemma Muslims face: because his shows, which now number in the thousands, are entirely in Arabic and, for some two decades, have been aired via satellite and on the Internet, millions of Muslims have been exposed to his relentless onslaught against their religion and their prophet—even as the guardians of their faith, the ulema, offer little in response but ad hominem dismissals and calls for his death for insulting Muhammad.  (As discussed here, one prominent sheikh, while being pressed by a talk show host to offer an answer to one of Fr. Zakaria’s many accusations against Islam, responded by yelling at the host and storming off set on live television.)

The latest strategy for dealing with Fr. Zakaria appears to be for Muslims collectively to pretend he doesn’t exist.  Anyone who ever raises his name during a televised show is immediately attacked for daring to name such a “despicable” personage. Even so, the quiet, ongoing efficacy of his mission is discernible, as evidenced by the frequent callers who tell him they were once Muslims who wished only to see his head on a platter, but that, through the years, they’ve come to embrace Christianity.

Which leads to perhaps the most effective aspect of Fr. Zakaria’s ministry to Muslims: he speaks their language in more ways than one. Unlike most Western critics, he doesn’t critique Islam from a secular point of view, by arguing, for example, that Islam is not conducive to “human rights,” or “gender equality,” concepts which have zero resonance with Muslims and can never supplant their more fundamental yearnings.

Nor does he behave as many Western Christians, never once criticizing Islam, but rather hoping to build “ecumenical” bridges with Muslims concerning “shared commonalities,” an approach well typified by Pope Francis and his ilk.  As for those very few Western Christian critics who do approach Islam boldly, they unfortunately lack the language skills to have any impact on or even be recognized by the Muslim world—not least because they cannot access the many untranslated Arabic texts of Islam’s long heritage, where so many of its lesser known but equally potent weaknesses lay.

And so, Fr. Zakaria appears to maintain his original mantle, that of a Christian evangelist boldly declaring the Gospel truth in order to save as many Muslim souls from, as he puts it, “the clutches of Satan/Allah.”  To that end, he has produced as many if not more episodes that have nothing to do with Islam and everything to do with bringing Muslims to Christ.

A final ingredient behind his efficacy is, ironically, what no doubt turns off many in the West: he approaches his topic the same way Muslims do—with passion, unrestrained and unfiltered, holding no punches, with not a little sarcasm if not outright ridicule.  In his recent episode asserting that Allah is Satan, for example, he sincerely and passionately yelled at his viewers: “When will you wake up to the truth?! Stop being fools!....Islam is a cancer in your bodies that must be removed before it’s too late!”  That Fr. Zakaria is currently 87-years-old and still going strong only adds to the effect.

It is due to all of these factors—that Fr. Zakaria speaks their language (literally and figuratively); that he has an expert knowledge of and regularly exposes Islam’s most esoteric Arabic texts and teachings; that the guardians of Islam are unable to respond to him, aside from name calling and death threats; that he doesn’t articulate his arguments through a secular but rather religious paradigm, offering Muslims a real alternative to Islam (Christianity, as opposed to default Western paradigms of humanism or materialism)—it is due to all of this that Zakaria Botros is having a profound, if unknown to the West, impact on the Muslim world.

Nor, I should add, is he alone. While this article has focused on Fr. Zakaria Botros, not least because he’s one of the first to pioneer this method of reaching out to Muslims—thanks first to the satellite and then to the Internet—he is today one of many.  In recent years, many others, including Muslim converts to Christianity—Brother Rachid being most prominent among them—have taken a similar approach on their television programs: presenting, questioning, and criticizing strange and problematic aspects of Islam—all of which are based on Islam’s own texts.

Such, then, is one of the most effective approaches to Islam—one that is naturally being missed by the West, in part because of the language barrier, but more so because the West, much like the Muslim world, rejects such an “abrasive,” “disrespectful,” and, ultimately, “overly Christian” approach to Islam.

 

Raymond Ibrahim, author of the new book Defenders of the West: The Christian Heroes Who Stood Against Islam, is a Shillman Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/octogenarian-priest-who-became-islams-bane-raymond-ibrahim/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter