Wednesday, June 1, 2022

U. Chicago SJP Condemns Pro-Israel Newsletter as 'Hate Speech' - Sara Dogan

 

​ by Sara Dogan

Attempting to censor the truth while promoting genocide.

 

 

In a brazen and unintentionally ironic letter printed in the Chicago Maroon, Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) at the University of Chicago condemned the David Horowitz Freedom Center’s distribution of a newsletter on campus exposing the terrorist associations of SJP and the Muslim Students Association (MSA) and urged university officials to thwart future attempts to distribute alleged “hate speech.”

The University of Chicago was recently named as one of the Top Ten Jew-Hating Colleges and Universities in a report published by the Freedom Center, and there was no shortage of evidence to support their place on that list.

UChicago SJP recently published an art zine titled “Cheers to Intifada,” referring to the violent Palestinian uprisings during which Jewish citizens of Israel were slaughtered because they were Jews. The zine contained violent imagery including a graphic of two lit Molotov cocktails raised in a toast under the heading “Cheers to Intifada.”

The zine was also rife with anti-Semitism including an image of a pig wearing a policeman’s hat with a Jewish star on it. Poems in the publication promoted ancient blood libel tropes against Jews such as one describing a fictional Polish teenager, understood to be Jewish and part of the IDF, who holds Palestinians captive while shooting "perverted bullets shot with animalistic lust yearning to rape bodies."

The student government at Chicago published a statement promoting the anti-Semitic BDS movement against Israel and used genocidal language calling to “free” Palestine “from the river to the sea,” a call to annihilate the entire state of Israel along with its Jewish citizens.

The Center for Middle East Studies at Chicago has also held multiple events featuring anti-Semitic speakers such as Rashid Khalidi and Michelle Hartman who demonized Israel and endorsed BDS.

And the same Chicago Maroon which printed SJP’s letter calling on the university to censor the Freedom Center’s pro-Israel newsletters removed an op-ed written by Jewish students objecting to “SJP’s Online Anti-Semitism” and published an apology for printing it in the first place.

Since the Maroon has a proven track record of censoring any speech critical of SJP or its allies, the Freedom Center was forced to resort to extraordinary measures to ensure that students at the university were made aware of the report and its contents. A Freedom Center operative hand-delivered over 5,000 newsletters containing the report on the increasing incidence of Jew hatred at Chicago and SJP’s role in promoting it.

The newsletters were distributed at multiple locations on campus, with copies made available in classroom buildings, dining facilities, student centers, and in distribution locations for The Chicago Maroon, the university’s main student newspaper.

U Chicago SJP was highly displeased that their near-complete control over the campus dialogue on Israel and Palestine had been disrupted by the Freedom Center’s newsletters. In a letter directed at the Chicago administration that was printed in the Maroon, SJP accused the Freedom Center of “defamatory printings” and “hate speech” and claimed that the Freedom Center’s publications “immediately and deliberately jeopardize the safety, security, and integrity of our community.”

“It is incumbent on the administration to condemn and remove these defamatory printings not only because they accuse the University of Chicago of being among the ‘Top Ten Jew-Hating Colleges and Universities’ in America and of fostering terrorist-affiliated groups. For Muslim and Palestinian students, the Horowitz Center’s vilification of student life poses a direct threat to community safety,” SJP stated in their letter.

SJP also accused the Freedom Center of attempting “to muzzle and disparage pro-Palestinian activism and scholarship”—a laughable claim given that this same organization previously demanded—and received—a retraction to one of the only pro-Israel pieces to be published in the Maroon in recent years. Not to mention SJP’s recent campaign to “support the Palestinian liberation by boycotting classes on Israel or those taught by Israeli fellows” which was advertised under the profane heading, “Don't Take Sh*tty Zionist Classes.”

Remember too that this same rhetoric calling the Freedom Center’s newsletters “hate speech” is coming from an organization which proudly published a zine that literally promotes terrorism against Jews and Israel, with images of Molotov cocktails accompanied by the slogan “Cheers to Intifada.”

So what did SJP actually object to in the Freedom Center’s newsletter? As evidence of our “defamatory” claims, SJP cites two key pieces of information from our report—that the Muslim Students Association was created by the terrorist Muslim Brotherhood organization, and that SJP receives funds from Hamas, an anti-Israel terror group. These statements are not defamatory because they are true.

As we have documented on our website, stopcampusjewhatred.org, and as numerous other authors and authorities have attested, Students for Justice in Palestine does receive funding through Hamas that is filtered through a third-party organization called American Muslims for Palestine. AMP is headed by the notorious anti-Semite and jihad supporter, UC Berkeley professor Hatem Bazian, the co-founder of SJP. AMP’s board is dominated by former leaders of the Holy Land Foundation which was successfully prosecuted by the US government for funding Hamas.

Jonathan Schanzer, a former terrorism finance analyst for the United States Department of the Treasury, testified in 2014 before the House Foreign Affairs Committee that “At its 2014 annual conference, AMP invited participants to ‘come and navigate the fine line between legal activism and material support for terrorism.’”  He described AMP as “arguably the most important sponsor and organizer for Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP), which is the most visible arm of the BDS campaign on campuses in the United States” and revealed that AMP “provides speakers, training, printed materials, a so-called ‘Apartheid Wall,’ and grants to SJP activists” and “even has a campus coordinator on staff whose job is to work directly with SJP and other pro-BDS campus groups across the country.” Even if UChicago SJP does not receive these funds directly, it benefits from the organizational apparatus which they enable.

Our claims about the Muslim Students Association’s ties to the Muslim Brotherhood are also factual. The Muslim Students Association of the United States and Canada was established mainly by members of the Muslim Brotherhood (MB) in January 1963 at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. Nyack College theologian Larry A. Poston writes that “many of the founding members of this agency [MSA] were members of, or had connections to,” the Muslim Brotherhood or Jamaat-i-Islami. The three most significant founders of MSA were Hisham al Talib, Jamal Barzinji, and Ahmed Totanji, all of whom were MB leaders of Iraqi descent. As is explained at DiscovertheNetworks.org, “The creation of MSA resulted from Saudi-backed efforts to establish Islamic organizations internationally in the 1960s, for the purpose of spreading its Wahhabist ideology across the globe.”

Did SJP even bother to fact-check our claims before labeling them “defamatory”? Of course not, because that is irrelevant to their cause. The fact of the matter is that SJP doesn’t care that our claims about SJP and MSA are true. They care only about scoring political points and shutting down pro-Israel speech on campus. Thus SJP claims in their letter that “This is not a matter of political discourse, and it is by no means within the scope of the Kalven Report”—referring to one of the University of Chicago’s foundational documents on academic freedom and free speech on campus. 

By SJP’s logic, calling for terrorist violence against Israel, depicting anti-Semitic caricatures of Jews as pigs, writing poems about Jews’ “animalistic lust yearning to rape [Palestinian] bodies,” and exhorting students not to take “Sh*tty Zionist Classes” all fall under protected and even laudable political speech. But publishing the truth about SJP and MSA do not?

U. Chicago SJP dismissed our carefully researched claims as “hate speech” while brazenly promoting Jew hatred, terrorism, blood libels, and genocide. The Chicago Maroon has likewise been complicit in this malevolent subterfuge.

By attempting to silence legitimate and urgent discussion on campus while engaging in a campaign of malicious smears and libels, SJP has displayed the ultimate hypocrisy of their position. The Kalven Report that SJP so audaciously cites in an attempt to censor speech critical of their organization, in fact ordains the exact opposite, stating, “There is no mechanism by which [a university] can reach a collective position without inhibiting that full freedom of dissent on which it thrives.” The administration of the University of Chicago would do well to take heed.

***

SJP’s full letter to the Chicago Maroon along with our response are printed below:

Letter to University Administration on the Hateful Horowitz Center Leaflets

Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of Chicago demands that the University administration take action to condemn the David Horowitz Freedom Center and remove its materials from campus.

By University of Chicago Students for Justice in Palestine  

Content warning: The following letter mentions leaflets containing antisemitic imagery and anti-Palestinian and Islamophobic rhetoric.

To the University of Chicago administration,

On Monday, the David Horowitz Freedom Center plastered more than 5,000 leaflets on and around campus demonizing Palestinian and pro-Palestinian students. These leaflets directly violate the University’s policy on posting on campus. In its text, the center accuses the Muslim Students Association, a recognized student organization (RSO), of being created by the Muslim Brotherhood (an Egyptian Islamist group) and Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of Chicago (SJP), an RSO that receives its financing exclusively from Annual Allocations and Undergraduate Student Government funds, of being funded by Hamas. The flyer slanders former Center for Middle Eastern Studies chair Rashid Khalidi as an “anti-semitic speaker” and characterizes specific University-sponsored talks that were not affiliated with SJP or any student groups as calling for genocide against Jews and spreading antisemitic lies. The articles include direct quotes from speakers at these events, suggesting that Horowitz Center affiliates were present and secretly recording. Most alarmingly, the back page of the leaflets, referencing the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement (BDS) against Israel, features two large swastikas and a photo of U.S. Representative Ilhan Omar (D-MN) juxtaposed against one of Adolf Hitler, with the headline “BDS: Finishing the work that Hitler started.”

As we hope you are aware, this is not the first time that the Horowitz Center has targeted the University of Chicago, its students, and its faculty with false accusations of terrorist affiliation and Nazism in order to muzzle and disparage pro-Palestinian activism and scholarship. In fall quarter 2016 and again in spring 2017, the center posted several unauthorized flyers around campus with Islamophobic and antisemitic imagery, accusing—by name—a group of SJP students and faculty (including tenured English professor W. J. T. Mitchell) of being terrorists and terrorist supporters. The posters included racist caricatures of students and professors and falsely claimed that SJP chapters across American college campuses are funded by Islamist groups. The University response was clearly inadequate, as evidenced by the fact that the center has continued its so-called “stealth campaign.” After additional flyers were posted in September 2017, Dean of Students Michele Rasmussen wrote in an email to the University community, “We have witnessed a campus poster campaign from an outside organization that targets individual University students and faculty based on their involvement with social movements.” By leaving both the Horowitz Center and the political cause it targeted unnamed, the University’s response emboldened the group to move forward with its targeted harassment and hate speech.

According to the website listed on the leaflet, copies have been “made available in classroom buildings, dining facilities, student centers, and in distribution locations for The Chicago Maroon.” It is incumbent on the administration to condemn and remove these defamatory printings not only because they accuse the University of Chicago of being among the “Top Ten Jew-Hating Colleges and Universities” in America and of fostering terrorist-affiliated groups. For Muslim and Palestinian students, the Horowitz Center’s vilification of student life poses a direct threat to community safety. And for Jewish students, the center’s use of Nazi iconography is traumatizing, and its conflation of fighting antisemitism with furthering Islamophobic hatred shameful.

It is clear that the David Horowitz Freedom Center is a source of harm to our campus community. It is also clear that its work aims to censor and misrepresent our academic production and to create an environment of surveillance and fear surrounding scholarship about Palestine. The time for equivocal action and ambiguous censure is long gone. In 2016, Rasmussen wrote that “while the University fully supports the expression of diverse points of view, the tactics at issue here are antithetical to [its] values and expectations of critical inquiry and debate.” These latest leaflets go further than opposing our values: By accusing the University itself of promoting “Jew Hatred and the Hamas Agenda,” they go so far as to incite hostility and hate against and within our community. They inhibit our capacity to work and study, to commune, to feel safe.

This is not a matter of political discourse, and it is by no means within the scope of the Kalven Report. It is, in fact, the Horowitz Center that endangers “the conditions for [the University’s] existence and effectiveness.” These inflammatory leaflets immediately and deliberately jeopardize the safety, security, and integrity of our community, and they must be responded to with the gravity and decisiveness they deserve.

We, Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of Chicago and our allies, call on the University administration to speak out against the David Horowitz Freedom Center’s deplorable campaign, in no such vague terms as before. We also call on the administration to work to prevent the center from undertaking operations like these in the future and to implement a policy against any and all hate speech posting, especially from sources not affiliated with the University. If the David Horowitz Freedom Center’s malicious activity is met again with impunity, then the center’s members and other hateful groups will be at liberty to infiltrate our campus again, posting whatever ludicrous and racist accusations they so choose.

#HorowitzCenterOffUofC #NoHateSpeechOnCampus

Students for Justice in Palestine at the University of Chicago is UChicago's chapter of a nationwide network of students committed to promoting justice, human rights, equality, liberty, and self-determination for the Palestinian people.

***

David Horowitz Freedom Center Response to the Chicago Maroon:

To the Editors,

In a letter to the University of Chicago administration recently published in your paper, Students for Justice in Palestine accuses the David Horowitz Freedom Center of “defamatory printings” and claims that the newspapers denouncing Jew Hatred that we recently distributed on campus “immediately and deliberately jeopardize the safety, security, and integrity of our community.”

As evidence, SJP cites two pieces of information from our report—that the Muslim Students Association was created by the Muslim Brotherhood and that SJP receives funds from Hamas, an anti-Israel terror group. These statements are not defamatory because they are true.

As we have documented on our website, stopcampusjewhatred.org, Students for Justice in Palestine does receive funding through Hamas that is filtered through a third-party organization called American Muslims for Palestine. AMP is headed by the notorious anti-Semite and jihad supporter, UC Berkeley professor Hatem Bazian, the co-founder of SJP. AMP’s board is dominated by former leaders of the Holy Land Foundation which was successfully prosecuted by the US government for funding Hamas.

Jonathan Schanzer, a former terrorism finance analyst for the United States Department of the Treasury, testified in 2014 before the House Foreign Affairs Committee that “At its 2014 annual conference, AMP invited participants to ‘come and navigate the fine line between legal activism and material support for terrorism.’”  He described AMP as “arguably the most important sponsor and organizer for Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP), which is the most visible arm of the BDS campaign on campuses in the United States” and revealed that AMP “provides speakers, training, printed materials, a so-called ‘Apartheid Wall,’ and grants to SJP activists” and “even has a campus coordinator on staff whose job is to work directly with SJP and other pro-BDS campus groups across the country.” Even if UChicago SJP does not receive these funds directly, it benefits from the organizational apparatus which they enable.

Our claims about the Muslim Students Association’s ties to the Muslim Brotherhood are also factual. The Muslim Students Association of the United States and Canada was established mainly by members of the Muslim Brotherhood (MB) in January 1963 at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. Nyack College theologian Larry A. Poston writes that “many of the founding members of this agency [MSA] were members of, or had connections to,” the Muslim Brotherhood or Jamaat-i-Islami. The three most significant founders of MSA were Hisham al Talib, Jamal Barzinji, and Ahmed Totanji, all of whom were MB leaders of Iraqi descent. The creation of MSA resulted from Saudi-backed efforts to establish Islamic organizations internationally in the 1960s, for the purpose of spreading its Wahhabist ideology across the globe.

By dismissing our carefully researched claims as “defamatory” without any discussion of the evidence and by attempting to claim that our newspapers are “not a matter of political discourse,” UChicago SJP is attempting to silence legitimate and urgent discussion on campus and has proven the need for us to conduct a “stealth” campaign.

Sincerely,

Sara Dogan
National Campus Director
David Horowitz Freedom Center

Photo: Twitter

 

Sara Dogan

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/u-chicago-sjp-condemns-pro-israel-newsletter-hate-sara-dogan/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Fact-check: Biden makes false, misleading statements about Second Amendment to reporters - Aaron Kliegman

 

​ by Aaron Kliegman

President says early Americans couldn't buy cannons, dismisses notion of Second Amendment as bulwark against tyranny, suggests support for banning 9mm rounds.

President Biden on Monday made several false and misleading statements about the Second Amendment amid his push for tighter gun-control measures in the wake of multiple recent mass shootings.

Speaking to reporters outside the White House, Biden was asked if there was one component of reforming gun laws that he thought could be most successful now.

Biden responded that the right to bear arms contained in the Second Amendment was limited from the outset.

"Remember, the Constitution, the Second Amendment was never absolute," said Biden. "You couldn't buy a cannon when the Second Amendment was passed. You couldn't go out and purchase a lot of weapons."

Historians and legal experts widely disagree with Biden that there were such restrictions on early Americans.

"It's an absolutely brazen lie," said David Kopel, research director and Second Amendment project director at the Independence Institute. "As of 1791, when the Second Amendment was ratified, neither the federal government nor any state prohibited the ownership of any type of arm. Of course, neither the White House nor any of its allies have ever supplied a shred of evidence to support Biden's claim."

Kopel, who also works as an adjunct professor of advanced constitutional law at the University of Denver, added that the Constitution itself undermines Biden's comments.

"Indeed, the Constitution presumed that citizens would own cannons," he said. "Art. I, sect. 8, gives Congress the power to 'grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal.' That is, letters authorizing privative individuals to attack ships of enemy nations. Any ship capable of combat in the late 18th century necessarily had cannons as the primary weapon."

Indeed, in the 1790s, the nascent and until-then neglected U.S. Navy had virtually no warships, so it repurposed private merchant ships, armed with cannons, for war, effectively commissioning them into the naval service.

Monday wasn't the first time Biden said early Americans weren't allowed to own cannons — he made the same claim earlier this year, last year, and in 2020 while arguing in favor of stricter gun control. PolitiFact and the Washington Post fact-checker both rated Biden's statements as unequivocally false.

"It seems highly unlikely that there were restrictions on the private ownership [of cannons]," Julie Anne Sweet, a historian and director of military studies at Baylor University, told PolitiFact.

However, some legal experts argued that while Biden's statement was factually inaccurate, the president was really making a larger point that's correct and more important.

"No one has ever suggested that the Second Amendment means no regulation of the type of weaponry individuals can possess," said University of Pennsylvania law professor Kermit Roosevelt. "That's what [Biden's] gesturing at by talking about cannons in 1791. That might not be true as a matter of history. But everyone understands that the Second Amendment doesn't mean that individuals can have nuclear warheads and poison gas, so obviously there is some limit."

Biden made another remark in his comments Monday that have come under fire. The notion that the Second Amendment exists in part to be a final defense against tyranny, he said, is wrong and antiquated, arguing it's fantastical to imagine a citizenry standing up to a government armed with fighter jets and tanks.

"And those who — not many are saying it anymore, but there was a while there where people were saying that, you know, the Tree of Liberty is watered with the blood of patriots, and what we have to do is you have to be able to take on the government when they're wrong," said Biden. "Well, to do that, you need an F-15, you know? Or you need an Abrams tank."

However, some experts counter that focusing on the mismatch of forces ignores numerous examples of citizens, especially in the form of insurgencies, succeeding against superior forces.

"Take a look at Ukraine today, Israel in 1947-48, the armed Armenian resistance to Turkish genocide in World War I, for examples of citizens with small arms who have sometimes been able to repel standing armies that wanted to inflict mass murder," said Kopel. "That's the reason that every government that has perpetrated mass murder since 1900 — including communist, fascist, Islamist, or other — has assiduously worked to disarm the intended victims beforehand.

"Citizens with firearms can't defeat a tank, but they can kill secret police agents who are killing citizens. That is why Mao, Hitler, Stalin, Lenin, Pol Pot, and Idi Amin (among others) always tried to disarm the victims first."

Biden himself recently witnessed the ability of weaker forces to overcome superior foes in Afghanistan, where the Taliban seized power last year after outlasting the U.S. military and the Afghan armed forces, which were armed and financed by Washington.

Roosevelt acknowledged that citizens can, without heavy weaponry, resist standing militaries if the soldiers lack sufficient will to fight but added, "You'd probably need pretty sophisticated weaponry" for the "'citizens take on the federal army' reading of the Second Amendment" to make sense today.

"To defeat the federal army in battle, yes, people would need weaponry that no one suggests they should be allowed to possess," said Roosevelt, who argued the Second Amendment "was actually intended to allow state military forces to resist" federal tyranny.

"We saw that happen — it was the Civil War, and the states lost," he said.

However, the late Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia argued in District of Columbia v. Heller, a landmark decision that found the Second Amendment protects an individual's right to keep and bear arms unconnected with service in a militia, that the founders created the amendment precisely to allow citizens to protect against a tyrannical government.

"And, of course, what the Stuarts had tried to do to their political enemies, George III had tried to do to the colonists," Scalia wrote in his opinion. "In the tumultuous decades of the 1760s and 1770s, the Crown began to disarm the inhabitants of the most rebellious areas. That provoked polemical reactions by Americans invoking their rights as Englishmen to keep arms."

Scalia continued:

"By the time of the founding, the right to have arms had become fundamental for English subjects. [Sir William] Blackstone, whose works, we have said, 'constituted the preeminent authority on English law for the founding generation,' cited the arms provision of the Bill of Rights as one of the fundamental rights of Englishmen. His description of it cannot possibly be thought to tie it to militia or military service. It was, he said, 'the natural right of resistance and self-preservation,' and 'the right of having and using arms for self-preservation and defence.' Other contemporary authorities concurred. Thus, the right secured in 1689 as a result of the Stuarts' abuses was by the time of the founding understood to be an individual right protecting against both public and private violence."

"How to make sense of the Second Amendment in the modern world is a difficult question," said Roosevelt. "Probably what makes the most sense is a right to self-defense when the government is incapable or unwilling to defend you ... It's easy to say that this is what the Second Amendment means with respect to state laws. Harder with respect to federal laws."

Beyond the ability of Americans to buy cannons and the chances of citizens fending off a tyrannical government, Biden also signaled support for banning firearms that shoot 9mm rounds, the most popular bullet caliber in the world, in his remarks on Monday.

The president discussed how some two decades ago he was participating in Senate hearings on gun control when the death rate was going up. He then recounted a purported conversation he had with a New York trauma doctor at the time: "I said, 'Why are they dying?' And they showed me x-rays. He said, 'A .22-caliber bullet will lodge in the lung, and we can probably get it out, may be able to get it, and save the life. A 9mm bullet blows the lung out of the body.'"

Breitbart News conducted a fact-check and determined Biden's statement that a 9mm round will blow an organ out of a body is false.

Biden then said there's "no rational basis for [high-caliber weapons] in terms of thinking about self-protection, hunting" and launched into his discussion about the Second Amendment.

"The Supreme Court said that arms that are 'in common use' cannot be prohibited," said Kopel. "9mm handguns are the most common type of handgun. So, a ban is plainly unconstitutional. And hypocritical. President Biden is protected 24/7 by Secret Service agents with 9mm Glocks."

The 9mm pistol accounted for well over half of all handguns produced in 2019, according to Shooting Industry magazine.

Biden's remarks came amid a push by Democrats to adopt stricter gun laws following the tragic mass shootings in Buffalo and Uvalde, Texas earlier this month.

 

Aaron Kliegman

Source: https://justthenews.com/government/courts-law/fact-check-biden-makes-false-misleading-statements-about-second-amendment

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Iran Not Waiting for Nuclear Weapons to Destabilize the Middle East - Khaled Abu Toameh

 

​ by Khaled Abu Toameh

The Iraqis -- would have preferred to see a law criminalizing working for Iran because they do not want to end up like Lebanon, which has been destroyed by Hezbollah.

  • The goal of Iran's mullahs is to spread their control to as many countries as possible by using their terrorist proxies, including Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad in the Gaza Strip, Hezbollah in Lebanon, and the Houthi militia in Yemen.

  • Iran's rulers are also seeking to increase their political influence in these countries. They aim to turn Iran into a superpower and major player in the Middle East at a time when US influence in the region appears to be dwindling.

  • Needless to say, Iran's mullahs are not only opposed to peace with Israel. They and their proxies have repeatedly stated that their real goal is to eliminate Israel.

  • Some even warned that Iran's real intention is to destroy and isolate Iraq....

  • "Iran, not Israel, is the greatest affliction for Iraq." — Farouk Yusef, Iraqi author, Al Arab, May 29, 2022.

  • The Iraqis, Yusef added, would have preferred to see a law criminalizing working for Iran because they do not want to end up like Lebanon, which has been destroyed by Hezbollah.

  • "The forces affiliated with Iran accuse everyone who refuses to be subordinate to Iran of seeking normalization with Israel." — Hamid Al-Kifaey, Iraqi journalist, Sky News Arabia, May 15, 2022.

  • This is how Arab dictatorships regularly seek to discredit the opposition or anyone who speaks out against corruption and bad government: by accusing them of being Israeli or American spies and traitors.

  • [T]he law may be used to target political opponents who have been protesting against the corruption of the ruling elite in Baghdad. The anti-corruption activists have often been accused by the government of being "agents of Israel." — Akeel Abbas, Iraqi academic and author, Al Hurra, May 28, 2022.

  • The law "radically and explicitly violates two of the basic principles stipulated in the Iraqi constitution, which prohibits enacting a law that contradicts the principles of democracy and basic rights and freedoms." — Akeel Abbas, Sky News Arabia, May 29, 2022.

  • Additionally, while Russia has been losing thousands of soldiers trying to take over Ukraine, Iran, without so much as swatting a fly, has been quietly filling the void left by Russians abandoning Syria.

  • Iran is not waiting until it possesses nuclear weapons to proceed with its schemes. Instead, it is spreading its aggression like a deadly virus to other Muslim nations.

  • Or do the Biden administration and the international community secretly want the destruction of Israel and the Gulf States?

Iran's mullahs continue to meddle in the internal affairs of Arab countries, especially Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and Yemen. Iraq's new law criminalizing "normalization" with Israel is yet another example of how Iran and its allies feel confident enough to continue with their malicious and expansionist schemes in the Middle East. Pictured: Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, receives Iraqi Prime Minister Mustafa al-Kadhimi in Tehran, on July 21, 2020. (Image source: khamenei.ir)

Iran's mullahs are continuing to meddle in the internal affairs of Arab countries, especially Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and Yemen.

This is happening while the US administration and other Western powers continue to delude themselves into thinking that appeasing Iran's rulers and signing a new nuclear deal with them will bring security and stability to the Middle East and the rest of the world.

The goal of Iran's mullahs is to spread their control to as many countries as possible by using their terrorist proxies, including Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad in the Gaza Strip, Hezbollah in Lebanon, and the Houthi militia in Yemen.

The mullahs' efforts, however, are not limited to the use of military force and terrorism in the four Arab countries.

Iran's rulers are also seeking to increase their political influence in these countries. They aim to turn Iran into a superpower and major player in the Middle East at a time when US influence in the region appears to be dwindling.

Iran's mullahs and their allies also want to make sure that no more Arabs or Muslims will make peace with Israel.

Needless to say, Iran's mullahs are not only opposed to peace with Israel. They and their proxies have repeatedly stated that their real goal is to eliminate Israel.

Now the mullahs have every reason to be satisfied. Their effort to stop Arabs from signing peace agreements with Israel scored an achievement when Iraq's parliament voted in favor of a law to criminalize normalization with the "Zionist entity," punishable with a death sentence.

The law is a huge gift to Iran and its allies in Iraq. On the other hand, it is a severe blow to those Iraqis and Arabs who want to make peace with Israel but are now afraid of Iran and its puppets.

"The [Iraqi] House of Representatives voted, during its session today, on a proposed law criminalizing normalization with the Zionist entity," the parliament's media department said in a statement.

The new law stipulates penalties, including life or temporary imprisonment, and aims, according to its first article, to "prevent the establishment of diplomatic, political, military, economic, cultural, or any other form of relations with the Zionist entity."

Iraq, in other words, is saying: "We will kill any Iraqi who dares to engage in any form of normalization with Israeli Jews." This warning, of course, has brought joy to the leaders of Iran.

Unsurprisingly, Palestinians were quick to welcome the Iraqi parliament's approval of the bill criminalizing normalization with Israel. The Palestinians have always been among the first to condemn any Arab who talks to Israel or seeks to make peace with it.

Rouhi Fattouh, head of the Palestinian National Council, the PLO's legislative body, said in a statement that the "honorable position is not strange to Iraq, which is historically known for its political and economic support for the Palestinian people."

Fattouh called on Arab and Islamic parliaments to follow the example of the Iraq's decision to criminalize normalization with Israel, which, he professed, practices the "most heinous crimes" against the Palestinian people and their Islamic and Christian lands and sanctities.

It is worth noting that Fattouh is a senior official of the PLO, the organization that signed the Oslo Accords with Israel in 1993-1995. Then, the former leader of the PLO, Yasser Arafat, sent a letter to Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin claiming that the organization recognizes Israel's right to exist.

Fattouh is a hypocrite: his opposition to normalization with Israel stands in sharp contrast to the Oslo Accords between the PLO and Israel.

Since signing the Oslo Accords, the PLO leaders, including Mahmoud Abbas, have been talking to and doing business with Israelis almost on a daily basis.

Iran has also praised the law, saying it was a source for pride and a sign of the "brave" positions of the Iraqi people.

Yet, while Iran and the Palestinians, including Hamas, were celebrating the new law, some Iraqi writers and journalists said that the law was counterproductive and served only Iran's interests.

Some even warned that Iran's real intention is to destroy and isolate Iraq.

"There is an Iranian desire to isolate Iraq from the world behind this law, which the Iraqis do not need," wrote Iraqi author Farouk Yusef.

"Iran, not Israel, is the greatest affliction for Iraq. Iran, which did not leave a place in Iraq without interfering in it, is seeking through a scandalous law to destroy Iraq's relations with foreign companies that will fear cooperation with a country that may at any moment put it on the list of countries that cooperate with Israel. And Iran is the only beneficiary of Iraq's isolation from the world while it is working to develop its global relations."

Yusef said that a majority of Iraqis have realized that Iran is more dangerous to their existence than Israel. The Iraqis, he added, would have preferred to see a law criminalizing working for Iran because they do not want to end up like Lebanon, which has been destroyed by Hezbollah.

According to Yusef, Iraq is losing its sovereignty, while its politicians threaten to boycott Israel, which does not interfere in Iraq's internal affairs. "This game is part of the Iraqi disaster," he lamented.

Iraqi journalist Hamid Al-Kifaey also warned that the new law criminalizing normalization with Israel would isolate Iraq from the rest of the world and make it subordinate to only one country -- Iran. Al-Kifaey pointed out that even Iran had in the past cooperated with Israel, bought weapons from it, and exchanged military intelligence with it throughout the period of the Iran-Iraq War:

"Iranian-Israeli cooperation was well-known, although it was not public... Anyone who reviews the records of the 1980s will learn about direct transactions between Iran and Israel, the most important of which are US arms sales, which amounted to $2 billion dollars a year."

Al-Kifaey wrote that the time has come for the Iraqi people to take a clear position on the Iranian-affiliated political forces "that seek to mislead them, play on their feelings and tamper with their interests in the name of principles, honor, patriotism and religion."

He noted that the issue of normalization between Iraq and Israel was anyway not on the table, which raises questions about the timing of the law:

"The issue was not raised in the first place... The forces affiliated with Iran accuse everyone who refuses to be subordinate to Iran of seeking normalization with Israel. These forces try to exploit the Iraqis' strong feelings towards Palestine and its people."

Iraqi writer and political analyst Akeel Abbas noted that violation of the new law "can lead to the death penalty or life imprisonment without any commutation of the penalty."

Abbas pointed out that the current version of the law could even criminalize "anyone who may read a book by an Israeli author that talks about the conflict."

He expressed fear that the law may be used to target political opponents who have been protesting against the corruption of the ruling elite in Baghdad. The anti-corruption activists have often been accused by the government of being "agents of Israel."

This is how Arab dictatorships regularly seek to discredit the opposition or anyone who speaks out against corruption and bad government: by accusing them of being Israeli or American spies and traitors.

Abbas complained that the law represents "an infringement on the right of the Iraqi citizen to think, read and speak ideas."

In another article, Abbas wrote that the law "opens a wide door to tyranny in Iraq... [and] radically and explicitly violates two of the basic principles stipulated in the Iraqi constitution, which prohibits enacting a law that contradicts the principles of democracy and basic rights and freedoms."

Abbas also warned that the law "will do more injustice to innocent Iraqis and lead to more ethnic tension in the country."

Legal expert Maitham Handal also expressed fear that the new law would be exploited to "muzzle freedoms" and used as a weapon against political opponents.

Iraq's new law is yet another example of how Iran and its allies feel confident enough to continue with their malicious and expansionist schemes in the Middle East, even as the US and other Western powers continue to search for ways to resume the stalled negotiations with Iran's mullahs over reaching a new nuclear deal.

Additionally, while Russia has been losing thousands of soldiers trying to take over Ukraine, Iran, without so much as swatting a fly, has been quietly filling the void left by Russians abandoning Syria.

Iran is not waiting until it possesses nuclear weapons to proceed with its schemes. Instead, it is spreading its aggression like a deadly virus to other Muslim nations.

Or do the Biden administration and the international community secretly want the destruction of Israel and the Gulf States?

  • Follow Khaled Abu Toameh on Twitter

 

Khaled Abu Toameh is an award-winning journalist based in Jerusalem.

Source: https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/18580/iran-destabilizing-iraq

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Why CNN’s Claim that the IDF Killed Shireen Abu Akleh in a ‘Targeted Attack’ is False - Hugh Fitzgerald

 

​ by Hugh Fitzgerald

The key is in the bullet that Palestinians refuse to surrender for examination.

 

 

Shireen Abu Akleh is the Al Jazeera journalist who was killed while covering the fighting around Jenin between the IDF and Palestinian fighters. Everyone knows the story by now, what we know and what the Palestinians, by withholding critical evidence, will not allow us to know, and should be clear that assigning responsibility makes no sense as long as the bullet cannot be examined, if not by Israeli forensic experts than by Americans. For the bullet is key to determining whether an IDF rifle fired the fatal shot, or one of the guns used by the Palestinian fighters.

Here’s the latest on this continuing story: “CNN suggests Al Jazeera journalist was killed in ‘targeted attack’ by IDF troops,” Times of Israel, May 24, 2022:

CNN said Tuesday it had conducted its own inquiry into the death of Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh in Jenin on May 11, and said the results suggested she was deliberately targeted by Israeli forces.

Let’s assume that an IDF bullet struck the journalist. How can CNN know whether or not the IDF “deliberately targeted” her? That requires it to read the minds of the Israeli soldiers in the middle of a situation where Palestinians are wildly firing hundreds of times in the direction of those soldiers. CNN should ask itself why the IDF would target her. What conceivable benefit would that bring Israel? Killing Shireen Abu Akleh, or any journalist, would of course do great harm to Israel in the court of international public opinion. The Israelis are not stupid. They might accidentally kill a journalist but would never do so deliberately. The only side that benefits from Abu Akleh’s death is that of the Palestinians.

The IDF said the allegation was “entirely unfounded.”

Abu Akleh was shot dead while covering clashes between soldiers and Palestinian gunmen during an IDF operation in the city. The Israel Defense Forces has not ruled out that Abu Akleh was accidentally killed by Israeli fire, but says Palestinian gunmen may also be at fault. It has said it can make no determination while Palestinians refuse to hand over the bullet that killed her for forensic examination.

In an item headlined, “‘They were shooting directly at the journalists’: New evidence suggests Shireen Abu Akleh was killed in targeted attack by Israeli forces,” the CNN network said it had conferred with experts to support the claim.

First, using audio from a video of the moment the journalist was killed, the network said forensic audio experts had identified that the shots came from about 200 meters away — the alleged distance between Abu Akleh and nearby IDF forces at the time of her shooting.

Second, it cited Chris Cobb-Smith, a security consultant and British army veteran the network identified as a firearms expert. Cobb-Smith looked at photos of bullet markings left on a tree just where Abu Akleh was hit, and said that they were indicative of controlled, targeted shots rather than stray bullets.

The number of strike marks on the tree where Shireen was standing proves this wasn’t a random shot, she was targeted,” he said, while noting that evidence of Palestinian fire during the exchanges showed “random sprays.”

Is it at least conceivable that a Palestinian, even if firing wildly, got off a series of shots in the direction of Abu Akleh, one of them striking her and the others within seconds hitting the tree that she was standing in front of? I do not claim the shots “targeted” Abu Akleh – I am sure the Palestinians would not have deliberately done this – but it’s not impossible that someone firing wildly might nonetheless get off several shots while holding the rifle In the same position.

From the strike marks on the tree, it appears that the shots, one of which hit Shireen, came from down the street from the direction of the IDF troops. The relatively tight grouping of the rounds indicate[s] Shireen was intentionally targeted with aimed shots and not the victim of random or stray fire.”

No, the “tight grouping” does not mean Abu Akleh was deliberately targeted; it only means that the gunman did not move his weapon while getting off several shots, one of which struck the journalist and the others striking a tree. 

The Israel Defense Forces has said that any deadly Israeli fire would have been accidental.

An unnamed senior Israeli security official told CNN: “In no way would the IDF ever target a civilian, especially a member of the press.”

In a statement later Tuesday on the CNN report, the IDF said it had been thoroughly investigating the incident since it occurred and that its interim findings had been unable to definitively determine the origin of the fatal shot; it reiterated that an examination of the bullet would likely enable a firm determination, but that the Palestinian Authority has refused to make the bullet available. “The claim that the gunfire was aimed [at Abu Akleh] is entirely unfounded,” it said.

It defies all logic that the IDF would want to kill a journalist – any journalist – but perhaps especially one so well known all over the Arab world, who worked for Al Jazeera, the second largest news outlet in the world. How could killing Abu Akleh possibly help Israel? We see what damage the charge has done to Israel, how much it has damaged the image of the Jewish state.

Meanwhile, almost two weeks after the death of the veteran Palestinian-American reporter, The Associated Press said Tuesday that a reconstruction it carried out lends support to assertions from both Palestinian authorities and Abu Akleh’s colleagues that the bullet that cut her down came from an Israeli gun.

It did not, however, accuse Israel of intentionally targeting her. It also stressed that its findings were indefinite.

AP had least had the decency — unlike CNN — not to charge Israel with deliberately targeting Abu Akleh. And, again unlike CNN, it said that its “findings are indefinite.” It recognized, that is, the need for others to study the bullet that the PA continues to withhold.

Can CNN, or the AP, explain why, after two weeks, the Palestinians continue to refuse to let any others – not necessarily Israelis – to examine the fatal bullet? If it came from an Israeli rifle, surely the Palestinians would want that to be proved definitively, which only an analysis of the bullet can provide. That would be quite a photo op, of the PA handing the bullet over to the Americans, so that the FBI could perform its own analysis. Why didn’t CNN reporters ask, as part of their report, the following: “Two full weeks after Shireen Abu Akleh was killed, the Palestinians still refuse to let the Israelis, or the Americans, or anyone else, examine the fatal bullet. This remains a mystery. The only explanation we can come up with is that the Palestinians have something to hide. Israel keeps calling for the bullet to be made available, to them and to others for analysis. We agree.”

That’s all Israel is asking. Considering the enormous toll this story is taking on its image, it’s a very modest request.

 

Hugh Fitzgerald

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/why-cnns-claim-idf-killed-shireen-abu-akleh-hugh-fitzgerald/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Jewish Prayers Now Allowed On Temple Mount - Hugh Fitzgerald

 

​ by Hugh Fitzgerald

But for how long?

 


Just at the end of the Six-Day War, when all of east Jerusalem, which includes the Old City and the Temple Mount, came into Israel’s possession, Defense Minister Moshe Dayan made a fateful decision. He decided that Muslims could continue to visit the Temple Mount, which they call the Haram al-Sharif, at all days and times. Jews, however, who had been barred from visiting either the Western Wall or the Temple Mount when the area was ruled by Jordan from 1949 to 1967, would be severely circumscribed in their visits, which would take place during a three-hour period in the morning and one hour in the afternoon, and only on five days of the week. But more fateful still was Dayan’s decision – he consulted no one – to prohibit Jewish visitors to the Mount from saying prayers aloud or even silently. He apparently wanted to placate the Arabs at the very moment when they had been so thoroughly defeated that they would have resigned themselves to whatever the Jews wanted, including exercising the right to pray openly and to visit for many more hours on the Mount. Dayan was not thinking through what such a policy would mean for Jews everywhere. 

Within the last few years, little by little, the Israeli police have quietly begun to look the other way when Jews on the Mount silently mouthed prayers. That partial victory in practice led three young Jews to pray openly on the Mount, testing the limits of the new policy. They were arrested, and their lawyers went to court to challenge their detention. The result was a ruling by the Jerusalem Magistrate’s Court, one long desired by many Jews, that undoes Dayan’s decision in June 1967.

A report on the new ruling is here: “Jerusalem court rules in favor of Jews praying on Temple Mount,” i24 News, May 22, 2022:

The Jerusalem Magistrate’s Court on Sunday ruled that Jews are now allowed to recite the Shema prayer and bow down on the Temple Mount.

The decision was taken following an appeal by the legal defense group Honenu against the arrest of three young Jews, detained after praying at the site. They received a 15-day restraining order.

The status quo at the site, administered by the Jordanian Waqf, allows Muslims to visit and pray there almost every day, while Jews are not allowed to pray there and can only visit the site on certain days at fixed times.

Judge Zion Saharay said that the recitation of the Jewish prayer “Shema Israel” presents no “reason that could lead to breach of peace,” saying three young Jews should not be banned from the site, as the police demanded.

“We are very happy with the court’s decision. It is time for the Israeli police to start arresting the rioters and people who commit crimes in Jerusalem, and to protect the inhabitants. They must stop dealing with esoteric issues while violating blatant religious freedom for Jews on the Temple Mount,” Honenu group lawyer Nati Rom said.

These Jews are being allowed to say a single prayer, the Shema, and to bow down on the Temple Mount. The “Shema” is as innocuous a prayer as one could imagine. It’s the Jewish declaration of faith:

“Hear, O Israel: The Lord is our God, the Lord alone. You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your might. Keep these words that I am commanding you today in your heart. Recite them to your children and talk about them when you are at home and when you are away, when you lie down and when you rise. Bind them as a sign on your hand, fix them as an emblem on your forehead, and write them on the doorposts of your house and on your gates.”

This decision was a victory for religious freedom, undoing what Dayan never should have done in June 1967. Alas, this decision may be overturned. The Israeli police have appealed the ruling. A report on that wrongheaded appeal is here: “Police Appeal Court Ruling Allowing Jewish Prayer on Temple Mount,” Algemeiner, May 23, 2022: 

The Israeli police have appealed the Jerusalem Magistrate’s Court ruling. They claim that allowing Jews to pray at the Temple Mount will cause an increase in “tension” with Muslims.

Well, of course it will. But whenever Israeli Jews assert their rights, from enforcing their property rights in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood, to praying at the Temple Mount, this immediately causes “tension” with the Muslims, who are unwilling to accept anything the Jews may do, no matter how innocuous or justified. Why must peaceful Jewish worshippers be prevented from saying prayers at the holiest site in Judaism because the Muslims threaten violence? Those threatening need to be put in their place, informed that just as no one is allowed to interfere with their Muslim prayers being said in the Al-Aqsa Mosque or on the Al-Aqsa Compound, similarly, no one will be allowed to interfere with the prayers of Jews on the same site. When the Jews started to pray silently on the Mount during the last year, the Muslims made all kinds of threats. The prayers continued to be mouthed. And nothing happened. There Is no reason why the Arabs will behave differently this time, when Jewish prayers are said (softy, no doubt) aloud. The Arabs will push as hard against the Jews exercising their legitimate rights as they can, but if they are met with what the Revisionist leader Zev Jabotinsky called the “Iron Wall,” they will back down.

Nadav Shragai has an interesting take on the controversy, and on the ”Shema Israel” prayer, here: “The Battle for the Temple Mount,” Israel Hayom, May 24, 2022:

…There is no phrase more Jewish than the basic declaration of faith in “Shema Yisrael.” There is no prayer more Jewish than the one that accompanies us from the moment we enter the world until the moment we leave it. And there is no more natural place to say it – quietly or demonstratively – than the Temple Mount.

We need to remind ourselves of these simple truths today, when Israeli policemen are dragging Jews who recite “Shema Yisrael” on the Temple Mount away from it; and when court cases are actually presented for the record as “The State of Israel versus ‘Shema Yisrael.'”

We now have the State of Israel going to court in the hope of overturning the recent decision of the Jerusalem Magistrates’ Court that Jews should be allowed to say prayers aloud on the Temple Mount. Let us hope that that decision is not overturned, and that the Israeli government treats Jews on the Temple Mount just as it treats Arabs. Yes, there will be some Arab riots, but after the expected tantrum, with a show of force by the police on the Mount, now protecting rather than prohibiting Jews saying prayers, the Muslims will in the end accept, with oriental fatalism, the new status quo.

 

Hugh Fitzgerald

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/jewish-prayers-now-allowed-temple-mount-hugh-fitzgerald/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Prager U Video: What the Soviet Union Taught Me about Freedom - Prager U

 

​ by Prager U

“I know that the truth is on my side.”

 


Ilan Sinelnikov was the first in his family to be born in a free country—the first to grow up with freedom of speech and freedom of religion. Those liberties didn’t exist in the Soviet Union, where his family was persecuted for being Jewish. Ilan attended college in the United States, where he aspired to hold a student leadership position. Because of his outspoken support of Israel, he was smeared, silenced, and blocked from that role. Ilan fought back and now encourages all Americans to speak up, tell the truth, and protect our country’s founding freedoms.

Ilan Sinelnikov is an Israeli American who serves as the President and Founder of Students Supporting Israel. SSI is an international campus movement with the mission of supporting students who spread the truth about Israel. For more information, visit www.ssimovement.org.

Check out Ilan's story below in the latest short video from Prager U:

 

 

Prager U

Source: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/2022/06/prager-u-video-what-soviet-union-taught-me-about-prager-u/

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Tuesday, May 31, 2022

Nuclear Iran NOT an "Acceptable Risk" - Peter Vincent Pry

 

​ by Peter Vincent Pry

One might also wonder if the CNAS study is an attempt to justify consequent U.S. retreat from the Middle East, not as another humiliating defeat, but as a prudent and wise reprioritization of resources to meet the threat from China.

  • One might well wonder if the CNAS study is a "trial balloon" from the Biden Administration to begin preparing the nation and world psychologically for the advent of Iran's "Islamic bomb."

  • One might also wonder if the CNAS study is an attempt to justify consequent U.S. retreat from the Middle East, not as another humiliating defeat, but as a prudent and wise reprioritization of resources to meet the threat from China.

  • President Biden is defunding nuclear weapons critical to U.S. national security, such as the SLCM-N and B-83. He is also still seriously considering abolition of U.S. intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs), and is doing nothing to accelerate desperately needed modernization of the U.S. nuclear deterrent -- despite increasing nuclear threats from Russia, China, North Korea, and Iran.

  • If America, the most benign and humane civilization that has ever existed in history, is capable of using nuclear weapons, what can be expected from the evil empires that are Russia, China, North Korea, and Iran?

  • At minimum, a nuclear Iran will be even more aggressive supporting terrorism against moderate Arab states, Israel, and the U.S.. Iran might well also arm its proxies -- many of which are officially designated as Foreign Terrorist Organizations -- with weapons of mass destruction, while relying on anonymity and its nuclear deterrent to escape retaliation.

  • Unlike North Korea, whose overt pursuit of nuclear weapons is used for atomic diplomacy and blackmail, Iran's nuclear weapons program is clandestine and may remain covertly secret -- because Iran plans actually to use its "Islamic bomb."

  • Expect the Center for a New American Security to weave more fig leaves rationalizing Biden Administration blunders and irresponsible policy as a species of wisdom. Coming soon, U.S. nuclear inferiority to Russia and China will be called an "acceptable risk."

Unlike North Korea, whose overt pursuit of nuclear weapons is used for atomic diplomacy and blackmail, Iran's nuclear weapons program is clandestine and may remain covertly secret -- because Iran plans actually to use its "Islamic bomb." (Image source: iStock)

The Center for a New American Security (CNAS), comprising largely former, mostly Democrat administration foreign policy and defense officials, in a new study — "Risk and Responsibility: Managing Future Iranian Weapons of Mass Destruction Threats" — tries to sell the notion that Iran armed with nuclear, biological and chemical offensive weapons will be an acceptable risk. CNAS is a source of staff and "expertise" to the Biden Administration. Unfortunately, their idea is preposterous.

Based on three tabletop exercises, the CNAS report concludes that "even if Iran acquires a nuclear weapon, the likelihood the regime will use it is low."

Therefore, according to CNAS, the Biden Administration is justified in its plans to "accept risks in the Middle East and against future Iran threats" in order to "better address the long-term 'pacing challenge' posed by China."

The CNAS report states:

"Washington is reimagining its global role, leading the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) to make difficult choices about priorities, resources, and risk to better address the long-term 'pacing challenge' posed by China. To do so, the United States plans to accept risks in the Middle East and against future Iran threats. Iran's possession and potential use of weapons of mass destruction (WMDs)—specifically, its nuclear program, chemical weapons, and biological agents—pose the greatest threat to U.S. interests."

Three table top exercises, according to CNAS, indicate that "the United States can better accept risk in the Middle East and revise its global priorities while still protecting core U.S. interests."

One might wonder if the CNAS study is a "trial balloon" from the Biden Administration to begin preparing the nation and world psychologically for the advent of Iran's "Islamic bomb." One might also wonder if the CNAS study is an attempt to justify consequent U.S. retreat from the Middle East, not as another humiliating defeat, but as a prudent and wise reprioritization of resources to meet the threat from China.

Since the Biden Administration's intelligence community estimates that Iran is only 8 weeks away from having atomic weapons, Iran is already a "threshold" or nuclear weapons state. Other senior national security officials have warned repeatedly that Iran probably already has nuclear-armed missiles.

On the other hand, CNAS and the Biden Administration may really believe that nuclear-armed Iran is an acceptable risk. Biden's administration is the most anti-nuclear in history, staffed and advised by anti-nuclear activists who mistakenly believe nuclear weapons have little or no military utility, are "unusable" and that nuclear employment is "unthinkable." Jill Hruby, for instance, Administrator of the National Nuclear Security Administration, responsible for maintaining and modernizing U.S. nuclear weapons, was drafted from the Nuclear Threat Initiative group. Biden's nuclear "kitchen cabinet" includes the Carnegie Foundation's Nuclear Policy Program, led by James Acton, that persuaded Biden to fund a study by Carnegie arguing against modernization of American ICBMs. In the Congress, House Armed Services Committee Chairman Adam Smith and Senator Elizabeth Warren are outspokenly against U.S. ICBMs and nuclear modernization generally, want the U.S. to adopt a "no first use" policy and reduce U.S. nuclear weapons to a minimum deterrent of a few hundred warheads.

Consequently, Biden is defunding nuclear weapons that are critical to U.S. national security, such as the SLCM-N and B-83. He is also still seriously considering abolition of U.S. intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs), and is doing nothing to accelerate desperately needed modernization of the U.S. nuclear deterrent—despite increasing nuclear threats from Russia, China, North Korea, and Iran.

To the Biden Administration, its deepening involvement in Ukraine runs unprecedented and escalating risks of nuclear war with Russia. For those, therefore, who genuinely believe in the mantra: "A nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought," the nuclearization of Iran should be thought of as a relatively small and "acceptable risk" to the U.S. and its allies.

Yet World War II was a nuclear war, fought and won by the United States -- and not the only time the U.S. has seriously contemplated the employment of nuclear weapons. During the Korean War, for example, General Douglas MacArthur wanted to use nuclear weapons against North Korea and China. President Dwight D. Eisenhower achieved an armistice in that war by threatening the use of tactical nuclear weapons. President John F. Kennedy and his administration contemplated the use of nuclear weapons during the Berlin Crisis and the Cuban Missile Crisis. During the Gulf Wars, the use of tactical nuclear weapons was threatened if Iraqi President Saddam Hussein used chemical or biological weapons. There are many such examples, such as Japan in World War II -- so long as the U.S. "nuclear umbrella" is highly credible.

If America, the most benign and humane civilization that has ever existed in history, is capable of using nuclear weapons, what can be expected from the evil empires that are Russia, China, North Korea and Iran?

At minimum, a nuclear Iran will be even more aggressive supporting terrorism against moderate Arab states, Israel, and the U.S.. Iran might well also arm its proxies -- many of which are officially designated as Foreign Terrorist Organizations -- with weapons of mass destruction, while relying on anonymity and its nuclear deterrent to escape retaliation. Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps is, in fact, the world's largest, deadliest terrorist organization, and is in charge of Iran's so-called "space program" that has orbited two satellites.

Nuclear proliferation, and risks of nuclear war by accident or design, will greatly increase as a consequence of Iran going overtly nuclear. Syria, Egypt and Turkey might go nuclear. According to one recent headline, "Saudis would develop bomb 'the next day' if Iran nuclear deal led to weapons capability: experts."

Unlike North Korea, whose overt pursuit of nuclear weapons is used for atomic diplomacy and blackmail, Iran's nuclear weapons program is clandestine and may remain covertly secret -- because Iran plans actually to use its "Islamic bomb."

Western analysts typically underestimate or ignore Iran's ideological motives for nuclearization, deeply rooted in radical Shia Islam's belief that the secular and spiritual worlds are in their "end time" and that Iran has a highest duty, as a nation is expendable, in service of holy war to destroy the "infidel" peoples, especially the U.S. "Great Satan" and "Little Satan" Israel.

The Congressional EMP Commission warns that Iran, armed with only one or a few nuclear weapons, could carry out an electromagnetic pulse (EMP) attack against the U.S. and/or Middle East allies, blacking-out national electric grids and other life-sustaining critical infrastructures, thereby posing an existential or "assured destruction" threat.

The July 2017 EMP Commission report, "Nuclear EMP Attack Scenarios and Combined-Arms Cyber Warfare (see also the 2022 EMP Task Force report "Iran: EMP Threat") describes several scenarios where Iran, for geostrategic and ideological reasons, carries out EMP attacks on the U.S., Israel, Europe, Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States.

The report warns, to quote one example:

"[An] EMP attack that paralyzes the government, communications, transportation, and cuts the supply of food and water might well trigger a protracted revolution or civil war, effectively destroying the state of Egypt and creating a zone of permanent chaos..."

A nuclear Iran is an existential threat to the U.S. and its allies and should not be an "acceptable risk" to the Biden Administration.

Expect the Center for a New American Security to weave more fig leaves rationalizing Biden Administration blunders and irresponsible policy as a species of wisdom. Coming soon, U.S. nuclear inferiority to Russia and China will be called an "acceptable risk."

 

Dr. Peter Vincent Pry is Executive Director of the Task Force on National and Homeland Security, was Chief of Staff of the Congressional EMP Commission, Director of the U.S. Nuclear Strategy Forum, served on the staffs of the Congressional Strategic Posture Commission, House Armed Services Committee, and the CIA. He is author of the books Blackout Warfare, The Power And The Light and Will America Be Protected?

Source: https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/18568/nuclear-iran-risk

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter

Ex-Hillary Clinton campaign lawyer Sussmann found not guilty of lying to FBI - Natalia Mittelstadt

 

​ by Natalia Mittelstadt

The next trial will be in October in Virginia for Igor Danchenko, a Russian analyst accused of lying to the FBI in connection with the collusion plot.

The jury in the trial of 2016 Clinton campaign lawyer Michael Sussmann on Tuesday found the defendant not guilty on a charge of providing a false statement to the FBI, after deliberating in the morning and on Friday. 

Special Counsel John Durham last year charged Sussmann with lying to the FBI, while working as a private attorney, for allegedly telling then-bureau General Counsel James Baker that he was not working on behalf of any client while providing him with data he said substantiated an alleged secret communications channel between the Russian Alfa Bank and the Trump Organization. 

Durham argued Sussmann was working on behalf of two clients, the Clinton campaign and former tech firm executive Rodney Joffe, when he presented Baker with two computer thumb drives of data and white papers.

The connection was allegedly a back channel to the Kremlin.

The Sussmann-Baker meeting took place Sept. 19, 2016, just weeks before Election Day.

The trial is the first in Durham's investigation into the origins of the now-debunked Russia collusion narrative. 

"While we are disappointed in the outcome, we respect the jury's decision and thank them for their service," Durham said after the verdict. "I also want to recognize and thank the investigators and the prosecution team for their dedicated efforts in seeking truth and justice in this case."

The next trial will be in October in Virginia for Igor Danchenko, a Russian analyst accused of lying to the FBI in connection with the collusion plot. 

Sussmann read a prepared statement to reporters following the trial.

"Good afternoon. I have a few thoughts to share now that the trial has ended. First, I told the truth to the FBI and the jury clearly recognized that with their unanimous verdict today. I'm grateful to the members of the jury for their careful and thoughtful service. Despite being falsely accused, I'm relieved that justice ultimately prevailed in my case. 

"As you can imagine, this has been a difficult year for my family and me. But right now, we are just grateful for the love and support of so many during this ordeal and I'm looking forward to getting back to the work that I love. 

"Finally, I want to thank my legal team at Latham & Watkins: Sean Berkowitz, Michael Bosworth, Natalie Rao, and Catherine Yao. They're the finest lawyers and worked tirelessly on my case. Thank you." 

He didn't take any questions. 

After closing arguments in the trial wrapped up Friday, the jury deliberated for several hours before being dismissed for the long holiday weekend. The jury resumed deliberations Tuesday by asking to see a couple of government exhibits. 

The trial lasted 11 days, including jury selection and deliberations.

Prosecution attorneys said during the trial that the material was "pure opposition research" and that Sussmann wanted an "October Surprise" in the 2016 presidential race. 

Sussmann pleaded not guilty to the charge and faced up to five years in prison.   

The trial was held in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia before Judge Christopher Cooper.

 

Natalia Mittelstadt

Source: https://justthenews.com/accountability/russia-and-ukraine-scandals/jury-sussmann-trial-continues-deliberations

Follow Middle East and Terrorism on Twitter