by Ben Whedon
At present, 18 states and the District of Columbia have passed the national popular vote into law. Constitutional scholars have serious doubts about the outcome of the certain litigation on the horizon. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact would not technically eliminate the Electoral College, but as laid out, would render it a nullity.
The November "blue wave" that swept across the nation seems poised to advance a movement to eliminate the power of the Electoral College and radically reshape the way the nation chooses its top executive.
For years now, Democratic-led states have banded together in the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, in which they commit their electoral vote delegates to the winner of the popular vote in a presidential election. Donald Trump won both the popular vote and the Electoral College in 2024.
Now that Democratic lawmakers have achieved trifectas in typically Republican states, they are well-positioned to expand the compact to include enough states to represent 270 electoral votes, the bare minimum needed for a candidate to win the presidency. While that approach would not technically abolish the Electoral College, it would in practice flip the presidential contest to a popular vote. But the constitutionality of the practice is very much in doubt and Republicans are sure to fight against such an effort.
“It shouldn’t get past the district court,” Attorney General Todd Blanche said this week on “Life, Liberty, and Levin.” “I am optimistic that the Supreme Court will never even have to deal with this […] we will take it to the Supreme Court if we have to.”
Some pundits, however, appear concerned that Republicans seem unaware of the severity of the issue. Writing for the National Review, Inex Feltscher Stepman, a senior policy and legal analyst for the Independent Women's Forum, opined that "it seems like the right has barely realized the importance of the fight that’s about to begin."
At present, 18 states and the District of Columbia have passed the national popular vote into law. But the initiative could gain as many as five additional states in the near future, given Democrats won trifectas in Arizona, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin. Should those states implement the compact, it would reach 270 votes and effectively replace the Electoral College.
Time reported that in order for a state to join the compact, it needs to pass legislation through both chambers of its legislature. The governor then needs to sign the legislation for it to become law—or, if they refuse to do so, the state legislature needs to marshal a supermajority to overturn a gubernatorial veto and enact the measure.
Gov.-elect David Crowley, D-Wis., and Gov. Josh Shapiro, D-Pa., have both expressed interest in reforming the Electoral College or switching to a popular vote system, according to SpotlightPA. But neither have started to move legislatively on the matter as of press time. Gov. Mikie Sherrill, D-N.J., this week endorsed eliminating the Electoral College during an appearance on MSNOW, saying “[o]ur votes in New Jersey are worth about one fifth of what a vote in Wyoming is. That’s not democracy.” Her state has already joined the compact.
At present, the compact is not in effect. It is not set to take effect until enough states join it to represent at least 270 electoral votes. Accordingly, legal challenges to the effort remain in their nascent stages. Republicans have opined on the potential illegality of the compact, but are unlikely to enter litigation until it takes effect, due to standing and ripeness issues. The primary legal challenge to the compact took place in 2019, in Miller v. Washington, in which a voter sued the state over its adoption of the compact. The court dismissed the case, asserting he lacked standing, thus not addressing the underlying merits of the legal and constitutional questions.
Compact would not have prevented Trump's second term
Switching to the popular vote system may not necessarily benefit Democrats. The compact does not take effect until it includes enough states to reach 270 votes, but had it been in place in 2024, for example, heavily Democratic states like California would have been forced to cast their electoral votes for President Donald Trump. But Democrats have their eyes on history, which has seen the Electoral College system almost exclusively work against them in contested races.
The loser of the popular vote has managed to win the presidency twice in recent decades. President George W. Bush pulled off the feat in 2000, while President Donald Trump repeated it in 2016. Both times, the system benefited the Republican candidate. Prior to the 21st Century, that development occurred only three times, in 1824, 1876, and 1888. The 1876 and 1888 elections both saw Republicans claim the presidency, despite a Democrat winning the popular vote. In 1824, John Quincy Adams became president after a deal with Henry Clay to keep out Andrew Jackson, the man who later became the Democratic Party’s first president.
Strictly speaking, members of the Electoral College may cast their vote as they see fit and so-called “faithless electors” sometimes buck the decision of the state they represent. Some states, however, force the electors to vote with their state’s electorate. That matter went to the Supreme Court over the 2016 election, after which some supporters of former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton urged members of the Electoral College to keep President Donald Trump out of the White House. The Supreme Court, in Chiafolo v. Washington, upheld state laws telling their electors how to vote. But while states can generally do what they want with their electors, it remains less clear that they can coordinate with other states on the matter.
States may decide who is a member of the College, but interstate compacts require an act of Congress
Article II, Section 1, Clause 2, gives the states clear authority over the manner in which they select their members of the Electoral College.
Each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in the Congress: but no Senator or Representative, or Person holding an Office of Trust or Profit under the United States, shall be appointed an Elector.
Article I, Section 10, Clause 3 of the Constitution bars the creation of interstate compacts without the consent of Congress.
No State shall, without the Consent of Congress, lay any Duty of Tonnage, keep Troops, or Ships of War in time of Peace, enter into any Agreement or Compact with another State, or with a foreign Power, or engage in War, unless actually invaded, or in such imminent Danger as will not admit of delay.
The Electoral College is not without benefits, some scholars say
The Supreme Court has previously interpreted this provision in a less absolute manner, finding that congressional consent is only necessary when such a compact would increase the power of the states at the expense of the federal government or other states.
Analysts at the Heritage Foundation have reported that the framers of the Constitution saw several benefits to the Electoral College system. Namely, they argue that:
-
The current system respects regional and cultural differences while uniting the 50 states under one federal government;
-
Candidates are forced to appeal to a broader cross-section of voters, preventing a "tyranny of the majority" over rural states and encouraging more moderate candidates over radical ones; and
-
Discourages voter fraud, because the impact of voter fraud is isolated to the specific state where it occurs because winning a state awards the exact same number of electoral votes regardless of whether the margin is 100 votes or 100,000. Thus, fraudulent votes do not carry over to influence the national tally.
The near-certain litigation over the popular vote compact will likely see battle lines drawn between two different visions of the future of America's presidential voting.
Ben Whedon is the Chief Political Correspondent at Just the News. Follow him on X.
Source: https://justthenews.com/government/congress/thublue-wave-puts-electoral-college-crosshairs-compact-nears-270-votes
No comments:
Post a Comment