by David Horowitz
The Father of Palestinian “Nationalism” and His Hero
Some conservatives, most notably Elliot Abrams, have criticized Newt Gingrich’s observation that the Palestinians are an invented people by saying that even if they are — (and there is no real question but that they are) — they’ve been around long enough (50 years, or since the creation of the PLO in 1964) so that we need to deal with that fact — not. What makes anyone think this is a people even today? Last spring I spoke at Brooklyn College. My speech was attended and then obstructed by a sizeable contingent from the Brooklyn College “Palestinian Club” — at least fifty people, all ethnic Arabs claiming to be Palestinians. During my talk I referred to the Palestinian death cult, its admiration for Hitler, its determination to wipe the Jewish state from the face of the earth, its eagerness to kill any Jew and to blow up its own children in the process. I said it was a “sick, sick culture.” But when the members of the so-called Palestinian Club erupted at me, what they said was “Why do you want to lynch all Muslims?” (This is on video available on YouTube or on our site — under “Videos” — for anyone who wants to check. It comes in the Q&A period.) This does not sound like a nationalist movement.
But the evidence is that Palestinians are a political fiction for a movement whose organizing desire is the destruction of the Jewish state and expulsion of the Jews is far stronger than this small incident. In 1948, 80% of the so-called “Palestine Mandate” had been given to the Hashemite minority in control of Jordan. The Jews were given half of the remaining 20% and the Arabs the other half. A nationalist movement would surely have accepted the partition and then laid claim to the 80% controlled by the Hashemites in Jordan. No such thing happened. Instead the Arab states including Jordan attacked the Jewish state with the intention of destroying it.
The upshot of that war was a Jewish victory in 1949. Whereupon Egypt annexed Gaza and Jordan annexed the West Bank — all the territory that had been offered to the so-called Palestinians and rejected by them. There was not a peep out of the Arab world — or out of the so-called Palestinians — over this rejection. Why? Because a Palestinian state was never their agenda. Their agenda was and is the destruction of the Jewish state and the expulsion of the Jews from the Middle East — or failing that, their absolute subjection as a hated minority without access to state power.
Hamas is not a national movement. It is a fanatical religious cult which seeks a Muslim Empire throughout the Middle East and — in so many words — the extermination of the Jews. That’s in their charter. Is there an objection to this Nazi agenda from Abbas and the “moderate” terrorists of the West Bank? Not at all. The PLO has declared it will not recognize a Jewish state, has said that Palestine will be Jew free, and has formed an alliance with the Hamas Nazis.
The agenda of the Arabs in the Middle East is not nationalist — that went out with the vile dictator Gamal Abdel Nasser. The agenda is Islam — an Islam whose prophet calls for the extermination of the Jews and whose leaders call on their Arab brethren to finish the job that Hitler started.
Source: http://frontpagemag.com/2011/12/13/an-invented-people-despite-some-doubters-1/
Copyright - Original materials copyright (c) by the authors.
1 comment:
Dear David, You are the only one so far, who has pinned the date of the creation of the Palestinian People to 1964, the date of the creation of the PLO. But you haven't identified who created the "Palestinian Arab People" or why.
It was the Soviet dezinformatsia. The PLO Charter was drafted in 1964 in Moscow. In it, in the Preamble, the term "Palestinian Arab People" appears three times along with their need for self government in Article 21. The facts attested to in the charter were affirmed by the first 422 members of the Palestine National Council, each hand picked by the KGB..
We have this information thanks to Major General Ion Pacepa, the highest ranking defector from the Soviet bloc during the Cold War. Why did the Soviets do that? It was very clever indeed. Since the 1920s, the Arabs had committed terror attacks on the Jews. The attack in 1928 or 9, was caused by the Arab Executive, a national anti-zionist movement, spreading false rumors that the Jews were trying to take over the Al Aqsa mosque. Some 133 Jews in Safed and Hebron were slaughtered. Again in 1936-1939 there were more terror attacks. These were all motivated by religious jihad The effort of the Soviet dezinformatsia was to reframe future events so that they appeared to be motivated by secular nationalism. It worked like a charm. See: Brand, "Soviet Russia, the Creators of the PLO and the Palestinian People". http://www.think-israel.org/brand.russiatheenemy.html
The quest for self government was similarly fictional. See: Brand, "Was there a Palestine Arab National Movement at the End of the Ottoman Period?" http://www.think-israel.org/brand.palnationalism.html
However, following 1964, two leftist Israeli academics wrote books trying to paper up the historical background of the Palestinian people. One was a historian, Yeohoshua Porath, the other, a sociologist, Baruch Kimmerling.
Post a Comment