As Democratic powerbrokers attempt
to pressure President Joe Biden into bowing out of reelection, his
departure could set up a messy selection process for his replacement
that circumvents the primary electorate and threatens to send the party
back to the days of Tammany Hall.
Biden, 81, has faced calls to step aside as the party nominee in the
wake of his disastrous performance in a CNN presidential debate against
former President Donald Trump. During that event, Biden often appeared
lost on stage and stumbled over both stairs and his answers, which
reignited longstanding concerns over his age, mental acuity, and fitness
for office.
Should Biden opt to step aside, it is far from certain that Vice
President Kamala Harris would be the automatic stand-in on the party
ticket. The imminent approach of the party convention, moreover, could
lead to last-minute jockeying for the top slot.
For much of the 19th and 20th centuries, Democratic Party politics
were dominated by Tammany Hall, a New York City-based executive
committee that maintained political control through mafia-like tactics
and behind-the-scenes power-broking.
A potentially brokered convention post-primary with little voter
influence could see the party return to such machine politics, an ironic
development in light of the party’s repeated insistence that Trump, the
Republican nominee, represents a “threat to Democracy.”
"President Biden's campaign manager saying he is absolutely staying
in the Presidential race sets the stage for a drama of 'the bosses
versus Biden'," former House Speaker Newt Gingrich posted on Friday. "He got 14,500,000 votes in the primaries. The bosses got zero."
"The spirit of Tammany Hall has returned to the Democratic Party as
Boss Pelosi, Boss Obama, Boss Schumer and Boss Jeffries seek to
repudiate over 14 million Democrats and replace the sitting President,"
he continued. "There is no precedent for Washington bosses throwing out
the votes of the American people to impose their will on the nation."
Heavy hitters seeking his ouster
Major Democratic lawmakers have publicly called on Biden to step
aside, while several more power brokers have reportedly done so in
private. Thus far, however, those seeking his ouster remain a minority.
Among the most high profile lawmakers urging Biden to step aside are Democratic Sens. Jon Tester of Montana and Peter Welch of Vermont. Rep. Adam Schiff,
D-Calif., this week also called on Biden to “pass the torch,” warning
that "[a] second Trump presidency will undermine the very foundation of
our democracy, and I have serious concerns about whether the President
can defeat Donald Trump in November."
Reports also emerged this week that Rep. Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., had shown Biden unfavorable polling data while Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer had privately urged Biden to reconsider his election bid.
Biden not leaving
But Biden, the White House, and his campaign have been adamant that
he has no plans to step aside and will carry forward to the general
election.
Campaign chair Jen O’Malley Dillon on Friday asserted
that "Absolutely the president is in this race, you've heard him say
that time and time again… He is the best person to take on Donald
Trump."
"That is not happening, period," White House spokesperson Andrew
Bates said of plans for Biden to exit the race. "The individuals making
those claims are not speaking for his family or his team – and they will
be proven wrong. Keep the faith."
Biden himself wrote to Democratic lawmakers earlier this month.
"Let me say this clear as I can. I’m staying in the race,” he wrote.
“I wouldn’t be running again if I did not absolutely believe I was the
best person to beat Donald Trump in 2024.”
The “voters voted”
“Joe Biden is going to be the Democratic nominee, period. End of story. Voters voted. He won overwhelmingly,” the campaign declared in late June.
Though the Democratic National Convention has yet to formally declare
Biden the party nominee, the process has essentially concluded. Biden
won every nominating contest with the notable exception of American
Samoa.
Facing challenges from Minnesota Democratic Rep. Dean Phillips and Hollywood guru Marianne Williamson, Biden overwhelmingly won
the most delegates in the primary, notching 3,896 of the necessary
1,976. “Uncommitted” trailed with a mere 36 while Phillips placed third
with only four.
Writing to Capitol Hill Democrats earlier this month, Biden highlighted his performance in the primary, asserting that “the voters have spoken clearly and decisively.”
“I received over 14 million votes, 87% of the votes cast across the
entire nominating process. I have nearly 3,900 delegates, making me the
presumptive nominee of our party by a wide margin,” he said. “This was a
process open to anyone who wanted to run. Only three people chosen to
challenge me. One fared so badly that he left the primaries to run as an
independent. Another attacked me for being too old and was soundly
defeated.”
“The voters of the Democratic Party have voted. They have chosen me
to be the nominee of the party,” he went on. “Do we now just say this
process didn’t matter? That the voters don’t have a say? I decline to do
that.”
Biden’s gaffes and age concerns aren’t new
While Biden’s awkward and stumbling answers during the debate have
been widely cited as the immediate impetus for the calls to stand aside,
such mannerisms from the president are hardly new and neither are
concerns over his age. The only new thing is mainstream media finally
broke their silence on the issue after Biden's disastrous debate
performance.
New York magazine's
Olivia Nuzzi, a long-time Democratic stalwart, wrote that there was a
"conspiracy of silence" regarding Biden's infirmities, and that although
reporters knew about Biden's issues, they refused to acknowledge it to
readers for fear of echoing "right-wing media."
The president’s reference to a candidate who “attacked me for being
too old” was an apparent knock at Phillips, who repeatedly highlighted
Biden’s age throughout the campaign. Phillips in January told Axios he believed that Biden would be unable to complete another term in office.
"At that stage of life, it is impossible ultimately to conduct, to
prosecute the office of the American presidency in the way that this
country in the world needs right now,” he said. “That is an absolute
truth."
Biden’s penchant for making awkward gaffes or telling questionable
stories, moreover, is a longstanding matter, and significantly predates
the 2024 Democratic primary.
The University of California at Santa Barbara
catalogued his record of plagiarism and fabrications going back to at
least the 1980s, including allegations from the Trump camp that as a
student at Syracuse Law School in 1965, Biden plagiarized five pages from a law review journal "without quotation or attribution."
During his failed 1988 presidential campaign, Biden plagiarized from
speeches by British politician Neil Kinnock, Robert Kennedy,
and President John F. Kennedy.
His awkward utterances, moreover, have been so frequent that Trump has compiled them for campaign materials, last month releasing a supercut of Biden’s awkward phrasings.
"America is a nation that can be defined in a single word:
aseemfhuuthimaafuutheemscuseme," he said in one. "All men and women
created by the go you know... you know the thing," Biden said in
another.
Current polling looks bad, but it’s only July
Polling data currently show Trump with a modest lead over Biden, earning 47.7% support to the incumbent’s 44.7% in the RealClearPolitics polling average.
But July polling has generally not reflected the overall outcome of
the November election. At this point in 2020, for instance, Biden led
Trump by 8.6%, but only won by about 4.5%.
In 2016, moreover, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton led
Trump by 2.7% in the same metric. Though she ultimately won the popular
vote by roughly 2.1%, Trump won the election.
Key blocs are lining up behind Biden
Even with Democratic calls for Biden to step aside growing, some key
Democratic blocs have lined up behind the incumbent president,
potentially reinforcing his resolution to remain in the race.
BOLD PAC, the political wing of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, on
Friday offered its endorsement to the commander-in-chief, with PAC
chair Rep. Linda Sánchez, D-Calif., saying “President Biden and Vice
President Kamala Harris have delivered for the Latino community and CHC
BOLD PAC is proud to endorse them for re-election,” according to The Hill.
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., meanwhile, held an Instagram
Live on Thursday evening in which she insisted that those pushing for
Biden to leave the ticket would not necessarily support Harris for the
ticket.
“If you think that there is consensus among the people who want Joe
Biden to leave that they will support Vice President Harris, you would
be mistaken,” she said, according to The Hill.
“A lot of people don’t love that we have the same exact match-up all
over again, which is to say that the debate didn’t change much at all.
It didn’t really change a lot in terms of people’s perceptions, in terms
of where the electorate is at and going into the debate.”
She further warned that replacing Biden could prompt Republican legal challenges to the choice of another nominee.